Towards Transformational Theology and Theological Education in Africa:
Collection of outlines of presentations and reports during 2020 webinars on theological education in Africa
For discussion and interaction
Collected by Dr. Sas Conradie
1
2
CONTENTS
1) Introduction - Dr Sas Conradie, Dr Chris Sugden, Dr Joshva John……………6 2) Perspectives from Networks of Theological Institutions in Africa………..10 3) Reports of virtual consultations, workshops and webinars in 2020…..….20 a. Virtual consultation on collaboration in theological education
and training
in Africa on 2 April 2020
b. Workshop on Online Theological Education in Africa, 27-29 July
2020
c. Virtual conference of leaders of theological colleges and
seminaries
in Africa, 9 September 2020
d. Webinar on funding theological education, 10 November 2020
e. Transformational Theology and Theological Education in Africa,
20 October 2020 and Profiling Transformational Curricula on 30
November 2020
4) Thematic areas……………………………………………………………………………………35 a. Context…………………………………………………………………………………35 i. Theological education in Africa: Trends & issues - Dr David
Tarus
ii. Challenges facing the church and communities in Africa - Dr
Richard Mutura
iii. The possibilities of collaboration in online theological
education in a digital Africa - Dr Nico Mostert
iv. Sustainability Lessons from African Christian College’s Tree of
Life Project
b. Transformational Theology and Theological Education…………57 i. Transformation From Within - Prof. Patrick Sookhdeo
ii. Rethinking Transformational Theology as a foundation for
theological education - Dr Chris Sugden
iii. Rethinking Transformational Theology for the Public Square
– Canon Vinay Samuel
iv. Why African Transformational Theology? – Prof Elizabeth
Mburu
v. Why Transformational Theology in Theological Education in
Africa? Dr Antoine Rutayisire
vi. The importance of holistic theological education to
transform communities and church in Zimbabwe – Rev
Rangarirai Manditowepi
vii. Transforming theological education in Africa - Rev. Lule
James Kenyi
viii. Is Transformational Theology Contextual Theology? – Dr
Kuzipa Nalwamba
ix. Grassroots Transformational Theology - A Pentecostal
Perspective – Bishop Joshua HK Banda
3
x. Training for the transformation of nations: Contribution of religious sciences to development – Prof Moussa Bongoyok
xi. A missional ecclesiology as basis for transformed theological education – Prof Dr Nelus Niemandt
xii. The importance of missional spirituality in holistic theological education – Rev Doret Niemandt
xiii. Restoring broken relationships as framework for Transformational Theology in Africa - Dr Sas Conradie
c. Online and distance theological education…………………………125 i. Why Online Theological Education? An Christian NGO perspective - Dr Sas Conradie
ii. Why Online Theological Education? A Teacher’s perspective - Dr Prasad Phillips
iii. Four Theses about Online Theological Education in Africa – Dr Kevin Smith
iv. Challenges and opportunities in online theological education – Dr Chris Sugden
v. Who Do We Say That We Are? Challenges in Online Theological Education – Dr Amélé Adamavi-Aho Ekué
vi. Creating online content – Dr Prasad Phillips
vii. eLearning & Theological Education: An overview of Africa - Dr. Daniel Singh
d. Methodologies to use and develop a Transformational Curriculum………………………………………………………………………….146 i. Pastoral training: A matter of balancing spiritual formation with academic scholarship for holistic transformation in
Africa - Ayobami A. Ayanyinka
ii. Strengthening Christian ministry through Theological Education by Extension: Methods and techniques – Rev
Babatunde Ogunlana
iii. Continuous Professional Development for the adoption of Global Learning to improve the quality of Theological
Education in Africa - Roy Tokunbo Olowu and Dr Tosin
Awolalu
iv. Theological Education and the Local Church; Paramount Players of Community Transformation – Rev Denis Ruhama
Onzima
v. Transforming theological education in Africa by engaging African worldview - Rev Hezron K Komen
vi. Engaging strategic management principles for transforming theological education in Nigeria - Simon Adewuyi Ishola,
Oluwafemi Samuel Amoran
vii. A Public Theology of Holistic Theological Education in Africa – Dr S. Trevor Yoakum
viii. Transformation through Discovery Bible Study Model Using African Family Network – Rev Benjamin Isola Akano
4
e. Examples of Transformational Theology Curricula……………….180 i. Grassroots theological reflection and theological education
through the Church and Community Mobilisation Process -
Passiri Levourne
ii. Model curriculum of integral mission to bridge the gap
between spiritual and social development in theological
formation – Prof Rubin Pohor, Dr. Y. Roger N’dri, Mr.
Mbairodbbee Njegollmi and Pastor Roudanaba Ouedraogo
iii. A Curriculum for Theology and Sustainable Community
Development - Rev Walter Rutto
iv. Wings of Eagle International Bible School Course: INTEGRAL
MISSION (God’s Heart for the poor) – Rev Jimmy Likagwa
v. Integrating integral mission and Transformational Theology
into the curriculum of ISTEL in Angola – Rev Avelino Rafael
5) Resources………………………………………………………………………………………...207 a. Theologyontheweb.org.uk - A Free Online Digital Library - Rob Bradshaw b. Global Institute for Leadership Development (GILD): Worldwide Network of
Theological Institutions offering post-secondary level education - Dr Prasad Phillips c. Resources for Theological Education and Training in Africa
5
Introduction
Dr Sas Conradie, Dr Chris Sugden, Dr Joshva John
Many church and theological leaders believe that theological education and church leadership training in Africa is at a crossroads. Some theological education and church leadership development in Africa is not relevant to the needs of communities as pastors and other church leaders are not properly equipped to engage their congregations in transforming their communities holistically. These expressions of theological education should be more contextual and the curriculum of some theological institutions more relevant to address the needs in Africa.
In 2019 a number of important African theological education and training related events were organised. They include:
● 4 regional training workshops organised by the Network for African Congregational Theology (NetACT) to equip lecturers at African theological institutions in dealing with contextual issues such as Public Theology, African Christian Leadership, Community Development and Missional Ecclesiology;
● A consultation organised by the Theology and Christian Education Commission of the Association of Evangelicals in Africa (AEA) on training grassroots African pastors and church leaders biblically and theologically to transform their communities.
With the success of the events in 2019, Tearfund decided to organize a consultation on collaboration in theological education and training in Africa from 1-3 April 2020 in Nairobi. Unfortunately, the global COVID pandemic broke out in March 2020. The result was that a face-to-face consultation was not possible. Given the interest in the consultation, Tearfund hosted a virtual consultation on 2 April 2020. 25 participants from 13 African theological networks and continental theological education initiatives took part. The consultation highlighted the importance of collaboration in dealing with challenges and opportunities facing theological institutions and training programmes in Africa. As COVID challenged African theological institutions to engage in online theological education, the Oxford Centre for Religion and Public Life decided to host in collaboration with networks of theological institutions in Africa, Tearfund and other organisations a virtual training
6
workshop from 27-29 July 2020 in online theological education. More than 300 leaders from across Africa took part.
The workshop was appreciated so much that theological network leaders in Africa organised a follow-up meeting for executive leaders and policymakers of theological colleges and seminaries in Africa on 9 September. The focus of this conference was collaboration in, sustainability of and further training in online theological education. More than 100 board members and senior executives of African theological institutions met online to consider how online theological education might contribute to the future training of African Christian leaders.
During the meeting on 9 September it was clear that the next webinar should focus on transformational theology and contextual theological education in transforming the church and communities in Africa. Tearfund and the OCRPL therefore organised a webinar on the way transformational theology and theological education in Africa can facilitate community and individual transformation in Africa. After a call for presentations and papers, this webinar, held on 20 October and attended by more than 100 theological leaders, engaged 17 theologians from across Africa who shared their perspectives on transformational theology and theological education in Africa. Many of these presentations included original perspectives that are relevant to theological education in Africa in a post-Covid context.
One question from the webinar on 20 October was the way perspectives on transformational theology and theological education in Africa could be included in curricula that transform communities. Tearfund and the OCRPL therefore organised in collaboration with networks of theological institutions in Africa a final webinar on 30 November to discuss curricula with a focus on transformational theology that could be used in theological institutions in Africa. 5 examples of transformational theological curricula currently being offered through theological institutions were presented. They included curricula that integrate transformational theology and integral mission into the whole curricula or specifically focused transformational theology and integral mission related courses.
Publication of materials
The presentations during the webinars, virtual consultations and online meetings in 2020 included important perspectives on the importance of transformational theology and theological education in Africa, especially
7
around online theological education. Tearfund and the OCRPL therefore include in this collection outlines of most presentations together with reports of the online gatherings. The aim of the collection is to facilitate further discussion on theological education in Africa and the theology taught through the curricula of theological institutions in the continent. Therefore only the outlines of the presentations are included and not the completed articles of the presentations. Some presentations will be published as articles in a publication intended later in 2021.
We started talking about transformational theology and theological education during the webinars in 2020 to encourage a rethink about theology, theological education and theological curricula to address the needs of the church and communities in Africa. We pray that a truly contextual theology can be developed that will transform the church and communities across Africa.
Various publications and events will take this discussion on collaboration in transformational theology and theological education in Africa further in 2021. A compendium with the major papers and proposals of the Association of Evangelicals in Africa Theological Consultation in September on scaling up theological training in Africa will be published in early 2021 (see https://aeafrica.org/scaling-up-theological-training-in-africa-2/). The Northwest University in South Africa is finalizing a book on critical engagement with theological education in Africa with contributions from across Africa. The All Africa Conference of Churches is planning a major consultation on the future of theological education in Africa. Progress is also being made by OCRPL in developing an MA in Transformational Theology and Sustainable Development. Further webinars on specific themes in Transformational Theology such as on corruption are in view.
The disruption in theological education in Africa and the inability to meet face to-face during 2020 opened new opportunities to look again at theology and theological education in Africa. We hope that this booklet encapsulates some of the emerging thinking and will contribute to the conversation about theology and theological education in Africa in the 21st Century that will equip the African Church for its transformational life-style and mission so that the Kingdom of God can become more visible in communities across Africa.
We greatly value the collaboration with the following networks, denominations and institutions in organising the webinars:
8
∙ Network for African Congregational Theology (NetACT), ∙ The Association for Christian Theological Education in Africa (ACTEA) ∙ The Oxford Centre for Religion and Public Life (OCRPL)
∙ Tearfund
∙ Global Institute for Leadership Development (GILD)
∙ African Baptist Theological Education Network (ABTEN) ∙ The Pentecostal Assemblies of God (PAOG)
∙ The Council of Anglican Provinces of Africa (CAPA)
∙ The Institut Universitaire de Développement International (IUDI) ∙ Le Conseil des Institutions Théologiques d’Afrique Francophone (CITAF)
For more information contact:
Dr Sas Conradie - sas.conradie@tearfund.org
Dr Chris Sugden csugden@ocrpl.org
Dr Joshva John joshva.john@ocrpl.org
9
Perspectives from Networks of Theological Institutions in Africa
Networks of theological institutions, denominations and specialist institutions in Africa are very important to facilitate discussion on theological education in Africa, improve theological education in Africa and accredit theological education in Africa. Each network, denomination and specialist institution has a specific function or service that they provide to theological institutions on the continent. Some networks serve theological institutions in specific Christian traditions while others serve theological institutions in a specific area. In 2020, a number of networks, denominations and specialist institutions in Africa started collaborating more closely to serve each other, the church and communities in Africa better. The various networks co-hosted webinars, led discussions, gave presentations, engaged member institutions in the webinars and facilitated discussions on the content and form of theological education in Africa. This collaboration will be essential to see the Kingdom of God advancing in communities and nations across Africa.
Association for Christian Theological Education in Africa (ACTEA - (acteaweb.org)
ACTEA is a project of the Association of Evangelicals in Africa (AEA). AEA established ACTEA in 1976 as a project of its Theological Education Commission (TEC) under the impetus of the General Secretary, Dr. Byang Kato. Kato believed that rigorous and quality evangelical theological education would most incontrovertibly cure African Christianity’s “theological anemia,” which he understood as the compromise of evangelical faith in the face of “syncretism, universalism, and Christo-paganism.” ACTEA offers accreditation, support services, and capacity-building programmes for Africa’s theological institutions. As Kato envisioned, theological education in Africa must contend with challenges facing the church in Africa. It must provide solutions. It must help the church to speak loudly and prophetically. All networks must work together to be successful in this endeavour. We need collaboration, networking, mutual exchange, and pooling of resources. It is through networking that scholars, institutions, and Christian networks can share ideas for mutual benefits. Networks open doors for research, writing, publishing, latest trends in a field, fundraising opportunities, and many other dividends. ACTEA is excited to work with other like-minded networks to help renew and enrich theological education in Africa.
For more information, contact Dr David Tarus at actea.africa@gmail.com
10
Africa Baptist Theological Education Network (ABTEN - https://ab316.org/, https://www.abten.org/)
The Africa Baptist Theological Education Network (ABTEN) is a cooperating body of Baptist theological institutions and committed individuals that long for and work toward healthy, biblically sound churches that exhibit both Baptist and African identities. ABTEN exists to impact local African churches through Baptist theological institutions, by strengthening and promoting sound, missional and contextual theological education that is rooted in the Bible and responsive to African socio-cultural realities.
ABTEN has a variety of goals but some of the most important ones are… ∙ Create pathways for collaboration, consultancy, and communication of “best practices” among member institutions:
∙ Advocate and model doctrinal and academic integrity and development.
∙ Promote systems of diversified missional theological education across Africa to better serve the local church and to prepare more laborers for the mission field.
∙ Identify and disseminate teaching methodologies, “best practices” and curriculum development which are effective, biblically sound, and contextually relevant.
∙ Facilitate scholarly theological research, discourse, and dialogue. For more information, contact Dr Kevin Rodger at kwr.in.africa@gmail.com
Institut Universitaire de Développement International (IUDI - www.iudi.org) Institut Universitaire de Développement International (IUDI), also known as the Francophone University for International development, is a private University Institute affiliated with the University of Maroua, based in the far North of Cameroon. IUDI's vision is societal development and transformation through leaders who respond to their communities and nations' holistic needs. Our goal is to be the best African French-speaking university in the area of holistic development. Being the best means providing excellent training to our students and giving them all the necessary knowledge and practical experience that will turn them into agents of transformation actively contributing to the movement of holistic development in their communities and beyond, thus impacting all the critical spheres of society (namely: spirituality, family, economy, education, media, entertainment, and government). The rationale behind this vision is that African French Speaking nations have more needs than the English-speaking ones, and most of the poorest countries on the continent are within their ranks. Sustainable Development appears to be a significant felt need. Our mission is
11
to train leaders in holistic development, equipping them with the latest theory and best practices and empowering them to transform their communities and nations. Such an educational approach requires a solid biblical foundation and an interdisciplinary approach as various studies inform holistic development.
Currently, IUDI offers degree programs up to the Ph.D. level in each of the following six schools: Theology, International Development, Business Administration, Intercultural Studies, Education Sciences, and Linguistics. IUDI offers courses both online and on-site. IUDI partners with various universities in Africa, Asia, Europe, and North America.
For more information, contact Professor Moussa Bongoyok at info@iudi.org, bongoyok@fuid.org
Council of Anglican Provinces of Africa (CAPA – https://capa-hq.org) CAPA, as part of her objectives, seeks to develop a theological anchor for the Church’s mission and ministry as well as to engage with people of other faith to use Holy Scriptures to mobilize resourcesfor the development of the continent. To be able to achieve these objectives, there is the need for the Anglican Church to have a strong platform to facilitate theological discourse and also to develop resources for the preparation and training of people in ministry. One of the ways to prepare ministers is through the provision of theological education that is appropriate, contextually engaging and relevant. This requires that theological education be dynamic to reflect the changing context of doing theology. The landscape for theological education on the continent however is very diverse and plagued by a number of challenges ranging from access through relevance to sustainability. While there are a number of Anglican theological education institutions on the continent, the focus, content and training context differ depending on the type of churchmanship tradition modelled by the Province (or Diocese) where the institution is based. The COVID-19 pandemic has so far been the major game-changer. The impact of the pandemic has long term ramifications on the delivery of theological education on the continent. To say that the pandemic has highlighted the need for new ways of delivering theological education on the continent will be understating an obvious need. The pandemic has threatened the very existence of some institutions but more seriously has also unearthed the lack of resilience in our institutional capacity to adjust to meeting the needs of stakeholders in the changing times. Based on the various engagements and conversations with the leadership of theological education institutions and Primates, the need to re-look at ways of doing theological education on the continent has become imperative. Based on the concerns raised in these conversations, it is envisaged
12
and is proposed to establish a platform that will facilitate continuous engagement and conversation between and among Africa Anglican Theological Educators and others on and outside the continent. The objectives of the forum will among others include:
∙ Creating a platform for sharing “best practices” to address challenges of dwindling enrolment, financial sustainability and the viability of institutions
∙ Provide a platform for exploring, identifying and sharing resources among institutions. Resources that can be identified and shared range from human resources and subject specialist, library resources, admission opportunities and faculty and student exchanges for experiential learning
∙ Serve as a think tank for theological discourses and for the development of theological resources to provide anchoring for the church’s ministry ∙ Generate and synthesis a theological anchoring for the work of the Church and her engagement with emerging and contemporary issues on the continent.
While the above objectives are not exhaustive CAPA and her stakeholders will seek to explore other opportunities and platforms that can promote, build synergy and enhance theological education and theological discourses from the Africa Anglican perspective.
For more information, contact Canon Kofi deGraft-Johnson at kofidiggie@capa-hq.org
Network for African Congregational Theology (NetACT -
https://netact.org.za/wordpress/)
The Network for African Congregational Theology (NetACT) is a network of theological institutions that started in the Presbyterian and Reformed tradition in Sub-Saharan Africa and that since grew to include institutions from various other traditions. It was formed in February 2000 in Nairobi, Kenya, as a network between theological institutions in Sub-Saharan Africa. These member institutions create and direct the network with the aim of assisting all members in preparing leaders for missional congregations. Congregational theology refers to NetACT’s emphasis on theology as practiced in the Christian Congregation as the Body of Christ; discerning the will of God in the process of interpreting the Scriptures specifically in the contexts of its member institutions; empowering congregations in these contexts to develop their strengths and gifts to theologically address historic, contemporary and future socio-economic, cultural, political and environmental challenges.
13
NetACT aims to assist member institutions with developing congregational theology, leadership and governance. It seeks to achieve this aim primarily through:
∙ the promotion of contextually-relevant training of congregational leadership
∙ upgrading of academic standards and institutional capacity-building ∙ developing and enhancing research within and among participating institutions
∙ developing continuous education programmes in and among member institutions
∙ promoting and facilitating lecturer-exchange between participating institutions
∙ hosting conferences, workshop, symposia, etc. in the field of theology in Africa and disseminating the results of these by way of publications ∙ addressing specific concerns in African contexts, especially by providing joint theological, moral and spiritual reflection in addressing these concerns
For more information, contact Dr Nico Mostert at missio@ngkvs.co.za
Pentecostal Assemblies of God (PAOG) Zambia
The Pentecostal Assemblies of God (PAOG) Zambia is the single largest Pentecostal denominational in Zambia, with over 1800 congregations amounting to a physical presence and representation in every district and province of the nation. PAOG Zambia is part of the Pentecostal Assemblies of Africa (PAOA) and currently holds the presidency of its Southern African Region Chapter, with a holding of over 4000 congregations in 10 countries. While being actively networked with sister theological institutions in the region, PAOG Zambia has anchored its theological trainings, in country, through its wholly owned Trans-Africa Christian University (TACU - http://www.tacuzambia.org/) by offering accredited degrees at Certificate, Diploma, Bachelors and Masters levels. Over the years, TACU has had the privilege of collaborating with ACTEA, TELTAC and other Networks of similar ideals, for the sake of advancing the cause of relevant theological education on the continent. The University spreads its services through 6 Extension Centres in selected partner churches countrywide. Several member churches run training initiatives offering supplementary bible training and church planting exposure.
PAOG Zambia believes theological education should never be done in a void. The Christian University, Seminary or Bible Institute is bound by God’s Mission to serve the church in a way that provides adequately spiritually formed and
14
appropriately skilled leaders, thoroughly furnished/equipped (2 Timothy 3:16- 17) to do God’s work. Theological education must therefore, aim continually for unequivocal Christo-centricity in a world whose value systems are challenged by unabating options. The premium remains on contextualized ministerial engagement that utilizes sound missiological approaches to assure relevance towards the sustained advancement of the greater missional cause
of the body of Christ.
For more information, contact Bishop Joshua Banda at
jhkbanda@northmeadassembly.org
Le Conseil des Institutions Théologiques d’Afrique Francophone (CITAF) Le Conseil des Institutions Théologiques d’Afrique Francophone (CITAF) is the recognized network of theological institutions in French-speaking Africa. CITAF was founded in 2005 in Lomé, Togo to encourage theological institutions in Francophone Africa to equip and resource present and future church leaders to take the gospel throughout French-speaking Africa. To do this, members must maintain academic excellence, reflect and consult together, and share learning and best practice. CITAF presently supports more than 100 theological institutions in 36 Francophone Africa countries including West Africa (Benin, Burkina Faso, Côte d'Ivoire, Mali, Guinea, Niger, Togo), Central Africa (Gabon, Cameroon, Chad, Democratic Republic of Congo, Central African Republic, Congo Brazzaville), East Africa (Burundi, Rwanda) and North Africa: (Morocco). Through this support CITAF hopes to secure the future of Biblical and Theological Institutions (BTI) of Francophone Africa, to contextualize the programmes of theological institutions and to be more relevant to meet the needs of communities in French-speaking Africa. CITAF is passionate about the difference that integral mission can make to the local church and wants to use its significant network to empower the region in its whole-life mission. We believe that this prayerful, coordinated unity will have a big difference in theological formation and fostering long-lasting connections between church leaders. For CITAF that unity is around the gospel - one that forms a community of brothers and sisters with our differences, in the realisation of integral mission.
For more information contact Prof Rubin Pohor at pohor.rubin@gmail.com or Dr Roger N’Dri at ndriroger@yahoo.fr.
Le Conseil des institutions théologiques d’Afrique francophone (CITAF) est le réseau reconnu des institutions théologiques d’Afrique francophone. Le CITAF a été fondée en 2005 à Lomé, au Togo pour encourager les institutions théologiques en Afrique francophone à équiper et à fournir des ressources aux
15
responsables d'églises actuels et futurs pour faire passer l'évangile dans toute l'Afrique francophone. Pour ce faire, les membres doivent maintenir l'excellence académique, réfléchir et se consulter ensemble, et partager l'apprentissage et les meilleures pratiques. Le CITAF soutient actuellement plus de 100 institutions théologiques dans 36 pays d'Afrique francophone dont l'Afrique de l'Ouest (Bénin, Burkina Faso, Côte d'Ivoire, Mali, Guinée, Niger, Togo), l'Afrique centrale (Gabon, Cameroun, Tchad, République démocratique du Congo, République centrafricaine, Congo Brazzaville), Afrique de l'Est (Burundi, Rwanda) et Afrique du Nord: (Maroc). A travers ce soutien, le CITAF espère assurer l'avenir des Institutions Bibliques et Théologiques (BTI) de l'Afrique francophone, contextualiser les programmes des institutions théologiques et être plus pertinente pour répondre aux besoins des communautés d'Afrique francophone. Le CITAF est passionnée par la différence que la mission intégrale peut apporter à l'église locale et souhaite utiliser son important réseau pour responsabiliser la région dans sa mission de vie entière. Nous croyons que cette unité coordonnée et priante aura une grande différence dans la formation théologique et favorisera des liens durables entre les dirigeants de l'Église. Pour le CITAF, cette unité est autour de l'Évangile - celle qui forme une communauté de frères et sœurs avec nos différences, dans la réalisation de la mission intégrale.
Pour plus d’informations, contactez le professeur Rubin Pohor à pohor.rubin@gmail.com ou le Dr Roger N’Dri à ndriroger@yahoo.fr.
Tearfund (https://www.tearfund.org)
Tearfund is a Christian international relief and development organisation that is passionate to see all people freed from poverty, living transformed lives and reaching their God-given potential. Tearfund was established to enable churches respond to poverty and disasters. With a focus on church and community transformation, Tearfund’s vision is a global church movement significantly transforming the holistic wellbeing of the poorest in communities. This means churches understand, embrace and live out its integral mission in communities and in doing so, improve those living in poverty in these
communities. Tearfund therefore works with and equips churches and denominations integrate Integral Mission Theology into their theology and ministry. This is often best being done through collaboration with theological institutions where pastors and church leaders are trained. Since 2016, Tearfund had been specifically working with theological networks and theological institutions in Africa to equip African church leaders to meet the spiritual, material, social and other needs in their communities. For example, Tearfund
16
is working with The Conseil des Institutions Théologiques d’Afrique Francophone (CITAF - the Francophone Africa theological network) in developing an integral mission curriculum that will be used in Francophone African theological institutions. Tearfund also has excellent resources that theological institutions can use in teaching (https://learn.tearfund.org/en/how-we-work/what-we-do/church-and
community). A very popular and practical resource is the Footsteps Magazine (https://learn.tearfund.org/en/footsteps-magazine/about-footsteps magazine). Our hope through is that a truly contextual and holistic theology and grassroots church leadership training is developed in Africa for Africa so that African church leaders will be equipped through the theological institutions to meet the needs in their communities.
For more information, contact Dr Sas Conradie at sas.conradie@tearfund.org
The Oxford Centre for Religion and Public Life (https://www.ocrpl.org) OCRPL is a registered charity in the United Kingdom. It has always had a close working relationship with Barnabas Fund, and in recent years have deepened this mutually beneficial collaboration. OCRPL was founded in 2010 by Dr Vinay Samuel with Dr Chris Sugden as a think tank, holding consultations and publishing studies with theological and mission leaders in the Global South. Building on their previous 25 years of experience in founding and developing the PhD and Masters Programmes of the Oxford Centre for Mission Studies with British Universities, they developed an educational programme with a Church Denomination in South Africa, which led to developing a PhD programme with Stellenbosch University in 2017. The first researchers enrolled at that time are now preparing to present and defend their completed theses. In 2018, OCRPL deepened its collaboration with Barnabas Fund and saw Dr Patrick Sookhdeo succeeding Dr Vinay Samuel as the Executive Director. Dr Patrick shared his vision for providing training to Christian leaders and theologians in the Global South, particularly among those Christians who suffer as a minority or even as the majority in some countries in Africa with Muslim communities. Through our links with Stellenbosch University, the base of the Network for African Congregational Theology (NetACT), Dr Sookhdeo was invited to share his vision with the NetACT annual conference in 2019 at Limuru, Kenya. His vision was to develop leadership among Christians who would strategically understand and critically engage with Islam and thus develop a better relationship with Muslims at all levels in their communities and countries. He suggested a programme to develop theological educators in postgraduate studies in the area of Islam: if every theological institution taught
17
Islam so that people could understand it from the inside rather than in confrontation or collaboration with it, then we may be able to train the pastors to provide strategic leadership in such contexts and countries. We signed a MoU with the Theology and Religion department at the University of Pretoria by which we offered courses on Islam in their already existing M Th in the area of Religion and Culture. The strategic vision was to produce 20 M Th students in two or three years and 20 to 30 MTh graduates in French so that we will slowly cover Africa with theological instructors and church leaders who are qualified with this M Th on Religion and Culture with a focus on Islam. We currently offer an M Th in Islamics with Pretoria (two cohorts) and IUDI Cameroon (two cohorts). It is envisaged that some MTh graduates will progress to Ph D studies. We are also launching an MPhil in Religion and Culture with a focus on Islam with Stellenbosch University towards the end of 2021, based on reading and an extended dissertation.
For more information contact Canon Dr Joshva John at joshva.john@ocrpl.org or Canon Dr Chris Sugden at csugden@ocrpl.org.
18
19
Reports of virtual consultations, workshops and webinars in 2020
Virtual consultation on collaboration in theological education and training in Africa on 2 April 2020
Dr Sas Conradie, Tearfund Theology and Networking Manager Africa
1) Background
African Theological Education and Training Networks and Ministries have an opportunity to ensure that theological institutions in Africa equip leaders with the needed understanding and skills to exegete the Bible and their communities and transform their communities holistically. That would require greater collaboration in theological education and training. A consultation was intended from 1-3 April 2020 to discuss collaboration in theological education and training in Africa. Unfortunately, this consultation could not be held due to COVID-19. Tearfund therefore decided to host a virtual consultant on 2 April. Despite technological challenges, 25 influential theological leaders from 8 countries participated in the consultation.
The consultation engaged with a number of key themes:
● Trends and issues in theological education and training in Africa.
● Challenges facing the church and communities in Africa. ● Challenges, solutions, opportunities, resources and most important issues in theological education and training in Africa.
● Collaboration in a book on theological education in Africa. ● Areas of collaboration in theological education and training in Africa.
This report is a summary of the discussion and possible next steps for each theme.
2) Theological education in Africa: Trends & issues (introduced by Dr David Tarus)
a. Main challenges and issues around theological education and training in Africa:
i. Development of and access to especially African
theological resources
ii. Educational infrastructure, including technological
infrastructure
20
iii. Development of contextualised curriculum and educational delivery
iv. Accreditation
v. Engagement with various stakeholders in theological education
vi. Financial and governance sustainability of theological institutions.
b. There seems to be a need to identify specialists who could assist with:
i. Accreditation.
ii. Resource development and distribution in various theological disciplines.
iii. Contextually relevant curriculum development and delivery.
iv. Networking to ensure that the various stakeholders are properly engaged.
c. Various networks and organisations can assist theological institutions in Africa dealing with specific challenges and issues
d. Working groups should be developed to address the key issues of accreditation, resource development, curriculum and educational development and networking.
3) Challenges facing the church and communities in Africa (introduced by Dr Richard Mutura)
a. There is a clear need to address specific challenges in communities and churches in which pastors and church leaders are trained and should be trained to address:
i. Leadership crisis
ii. Socio-cultural issues, including values and practices
iii. Economic issues and especially poverty
iv. Spiritual challenges such as discipleship, secularism and religious radicalism
v. Environmental crisis
vi. Weak states as reflected in lack of political and other areas of accountability
b. Models of theological training, including spiritual formation, developing a culture of discipleship, should be identified to equip leaders to deal for these challenges.
21
c. There are many opportunities for theological education including the growth of the church in Africa, the role of the church in African society and the cultural heritage.
4) Challenges, solutions, opportunities, resources and most important issues
After an interactive discussion, the following emerged as main focus areas and opportunities for theological education and training in Africa:
a. Focus areas
i. Collaboration and networking in theological
education and training.
ii. Contextual curriculum development and delivery.
iii. New models of theological education in collaboration with churches.
iv. Access to books, finance, teachers and other resources.
v. Accreditation and quality of education.
vi. Development of African scholars and writers.
vii. Discipleship and spiritual formation.
b. Opportunities
i. Growing churches and wholistic spirituality in Africa
that takes the spiritual, economic and social aspects
of spiritual formation seriously.
ii. The world is turning to religious organisations such as churches for solutions.
iii. Use of different models of theological education and training.
iv. Growing number of competent African theological scholars.
v. Engaging with Africa’s youth population.
vi. Lay movements in churches.
vii. Resources in communities.
viii. Growing collaboration including theological education and training.
22
5) Collaboration in a book on theological education in Africa that will be published by North-West University (introduced by Prof Hannes Knoetze and Prof Alfred Brunsden)1
a. There is wide support for the publication of the book that North-West University in South Africa aim to publish in 2021 with chapters submitted by October 2020
b. The book should be authentic Africa and should be the start of a much bigger initiative to review and reimagine theological education and training in Africa.
c. The African theological education fraternity should own the concept.
d. The book could be possibly updated every second year. 6) Areas of collaboration in theological education and training in Africa a. Collaborate in publications such as the book on Theological Education in Africa
b. Collaborate with NetACT in the online theological journal. c. Create an ongoing online forum to share best practices and post resources.
d. Facilitate collaboration around practical issues, challenges and opportunities facing theological institutions and training programmes including contextual curriculum and educational development, library resources, publications, accreditation, networking, mentoring and sharing platforms
e. Develop opportunities to engage institutions, theologians and practitioners
f. Form working groups around contextual issues and opportunities
g. Zoom meetings and webinars
h. Possible face to face consultation
i. The concept of a Consortium for Theological Education and Training is essential and should be taken further to facilitate collaboration in theological education in Africa.
1For more information contact Prof Hannes Knoetze at
Johannes.Knoetze@up.ac.za and Prof Brunsden at
Alfred.Brunsdon@nwu.ac.za
23
Workshop on Online Workshop on Theological eLearning Africa 27-29 July 2020
Hosted by the Oxford Centre for Religion and Public Life (OCRPL), Barnabas Fund, and the Global Institute for Leadership Development (GILD). In association with the Network forAfricanCongregational Theology (NetACT), the Association for Christian Theological Education inAfrica (ACTEA), AfricaBaptist Theological Education Network (ABTEN), The Council of Anglican Provinces ofAfrica (CAPA), The Association of Pentecostal Theological Education in Africa(APTEA), SouthAfricanTheological Seminary (SATS), Globethics.net, KLESIS, Tearfund, theologyontheweb.org and others.
1) Overview
a. This past year has brought a great deal of challenges to theological institutions and education in Africa. These challenges will result in significant changes to the way these institutions deliver theological training and education in the future. However, in God’sprovidence these challenges are not without opportunity. The opportunity being the chance to move and deliver a significant portion of training and resources online. As such, a number of networks and organisations collaborated to organise a three-day Online Workshop, hosted by GILD, Barnabas Fund and the Oxford Centre for Religion and Public Life, to help explain how these institutions could successfully adopt and adapt to online theological education.
b. Over the three days, a variety of content was covered and 350+ leaders and educators attended. The first day was spent casting the vision for theological training –explaining the need for online theological training and how this can be possible. The final two days focused on the practical side of online teaching and education, such as creating audio-visual content, accessing online resources, and using online platforms to deliver content. For many participants, online theological training was a new concept altogether and it was enthusiastically received. Attendees commented that, “The workshop was very insightful and interesting.”, “The program
24
was educative and timely.”, and “This was a huge eye opener!”
c. Moving forward, we are hoping to offer more training opportunities and support for these institutions. Not only was the conference pertinent for this moment, but it also provided a unique space to bring together scholars, educators, and facilitators from all across Africa. As such, our hope is that we can serve as a platform for continued collaboration and sharing of resources as we journey with one another for the furtherance of the Gospel and the strengthening of God’s church.
2) African countries represented
Angola, Botswana, Burundi, Cote d’Ivoire, Cameroon, DRC, eSwatini, Ethiopia, Ghana, Kenya, Lesotho, Liberia, Madagascar, Malawi, Mauritius, Mozambique, Namibia, Nigeria, South Africa, South Sudan, Sudan, Tanzania Togo, Uganda, Zambia, Zimbabwe.
3) Value of the workshop
7
25
4) Further action
a. Three Categories of Online Training
i. Not yet started: Funding Issues
ii. Just beginning: Some planning to move to digital
classroom and training staff to operate these
systems
iii. Already doing: Some seeking to improve existing
online delivery
b. In what areas would you like a future workshop?
i. Creating Online Courses
1. Quality assurance and copyright
2. Further development of Francophone
teaching
3. Lesson planning and delivery
ii. Delivering Online Courses
1. More technical LMS teaching and advice on
managing systems
2. Further training on integrating multimedia
into online teaching
3. How to ensure academic excellence in
online education
iii. Other
1. Training for Library Staff
2. Basic IT training: use of Zoom; security
systems, etc…
26
c. What other topics or skills do you feel your institution would benefit from?
i. IT skills
1. Further training on integrating multimedia
into online teaching
2. Developing and preparing quality online
content
ii. Non IT Skills
1. More info on GILD program and Shepherd’s
Academy
2. Finance management and administration
3. Global Trends and Theological Education in
the 21st Century
4. Specifics on online theological education
(OTE) in Africa, inclusive of how to
overcome the challenges in both urban and
rural areas.
5. Biblical hermeneutics and practical
teaching skills
27
Virtual conference of leaders of theological colleges and seminaries in Africa, 9 September 2020
Collaboration and sustainability in African online theological education – review of virtual conference of leaders of theological colleges and seminaries in Africa on 9 September 2020
Dr Chris Sugden
Over 100 board members and senior executives of African theological institutions met online to consider how online theological education might contribute to the future training of African Christian leaders. The conference on September 9 was facilitated by the Oxford Centre for Religion and Public Life and the Global Institute for Leadership Development. Major theological networks in Africa, the Council of the African Provinces of Africa, represented by the General Secretary, the Venerable Kofi deGraft-Johnson, the Network for African Congregational Theology, the Africa Baptist Theological Education Network, Tearfund, the Association for Christian Theological Education in Africa, and the Association for Pentecostal Theological Education in Africa came together to discuss and explore possible ways forward.
Dr Patrick Sookhdeo, the director of OCRPL, urged that while COVID had come out of the blue, Paul’s example (Philippians 1.5) should be followed, to acknowledge God’s hand in and embrace what had happened and be confident that He would provide, care and meet their needs. Tertiary education would now include blended learning, combining in person and online modes. There is no going back. This would require new mindsets among both staff and students.
New mindset
In online education, students could suffer distraction through the need to attend funerals or see to shopping. Digitality opens the door to plagiarism. Software and learning platforms are expensive. Some churches are unwilling to accept pastors trained online. Another obstacle is foreign donors, who contribute sixty to seventy percent of current costs and want to maintain their own institutions with their distinctive doctrines.
The many advantages include the end of the need to travel, the ability to access scholars and libraries around the world and with the rise of African academia to bring African theological knowledge to a global audience. Spiritual
28
formation, character development and discipline which are part of residential training can be outsourced to local churches and alumni.
The new mindset requires three c’s - co-operation, co-ordination and collaboration. Co-operation is short term and voluntary on shared information and office space. Co-ordination orchestrates people, tasks and resources in joint planning. Collaboration requires institutional and culture change, communication, competence and trust. It is also key to the sustainability of African theological education.
A new mindset is required among teachers who will no longer be the sole repositories and communicators of knowledge. Being a good scholar does not equal being a good educator. Online learning does not recreate the classroom, which only actively engages ten per cent of those attending, nor extends the pulpit. It must help the creativity of adult students.
Attitude not technology
Dr Kevin Smith, who pioneered online education through the South African Theological Seminary said that such students covered material five times faster and retention of students increased by sixty percent. Ninety percent of success depends on the attitude of senior leaders and teachers and ten per cent on aptitude. Technology is not the focus as people with the right attitude can figure out the technology. “Curiosity plus you-tube equals proficiency” he said. Bringing in IT experts is useless. The focus must be on a learner centred approach where people are engaged, work in community and have to participate. He encouraged current lecturers to enrol in well-designed e learning courses themselves to see how technology is used as “ we teach the way we were taught”, and course designers to work in teams, not in isolation.
Sustainability
Examples of the three ‘c’s were shared in small break out groups. Some institutions had invested in solar panels, often in stages, and one claimed 24 hour continuous electrical supply from its panels. Others used their many acres of land, (40, 51, 65, or 125) for farming, whether with piggeries, growing macademia nuts on 14,000 trees for export, or leasing it to a dairy company and using biogas for their kitchens. Students also earnt income by working on the farms. Investment in grain farming was subject to price fluctuations. One built student accommodation for the nearby university on their land as a source of income, others let out accommodation in the holidays as a guest house and
29
retreat centre. Another had started a high school in their grounds. One had leased land on their high ground for a telecom tower. Keeping the community of staff, students and workers together was emphasized for any ‘bounce forward’. Such investment had enabled colleges to reduce their energy bills significantly or subsidise their fees by 50%. There is also a shift to community focused short theological courses instead of full-time students only.
Bishop Joshua Banda of Malawi, who leads a network of 4000 Pentecostal churches across Africa concluded that “pooling what we have makes kingdom sense, expressing the stewardship to which Jesus calls us.”
30
Webinar on funding theological education, 10 November 2020
90% of Pastors Lack Proper Theological Training, Major Conference is Told2 Dr Chris Sugden
90% of pastors have no formal theological education, a specialist in theological education in the Global South has told an international consultation. Dr Manfred Kohl, who has experience in supporting and financing ministry training, explained that for this reason he funds only people – and not buildings. He also challenges institutions and their funders to think radical thoughts about theological education.
Representatives of theological education networks from the South Pacific, East and South Asia and across Africa – speaking for over 300 institutions – met with a large number of funding agencies to address these questions at the event. The consultation was arranged by the Oxford Centre for Religion and Public Life (OCRPL), and chaired by Dr Joshva John, Co-Dean of OCRPL.
Chris Sugden writes: This situation prompts evaluation of how effective theological education is. In Africa Christians form a sizeable community, if not the majority in some countries. Yet Africa remains the poorest continent. How might theological training enable people to lead Christian communities to engage with their neighbourhoods so that they can transform them spiritually, socially, and economically? Dr Sas Conradie of Tear Fund has been working for some months alongside OCRPL with networks of theological training institutions to explore training curricula that enable such ‘holistic’ theology and mission.
Global Cast of Lecturers
Online education is here to stay. Theological Education by Extension has been in place in the Global South for over 40 years, using local pastors as mentors for small tutorial groups of trainees embedded in the life of their local churches. Residential education was required to bring students and qualified lecturers together in one place with the physical books needed for study. Digitisation and the Internet now have the capacity to provide both a wider range of resources ( through online libraries) and access to a global cast of ‘lecturers’. The
2 This report was published in Evangelicals Now - 90% of pastors lack proper theological training, major conference is told | Evangelicals Now (e-n.org.uk)
31
development is the same as the ‘replacement’ of the stage coach by the railways.
A number of points need to be noted. Investment is needed in providing access to good Internet connections either in an already existing institution or by using commercial centres. Students need to have their own laptops or iPads. While expensive, these cost less than travel to and residence in an institution.
The need to train ‘students’ to enable their Christian communities to be agents of transformation requires that they take part in placements to experience and be involved in such activity on the ground, much as medical students do placements on hospital wards.
The need to form character as well as feed the intellect requires ‘blended learning’, where students develop ‘face-to-face’ relationships with fellow students and mentors. One speaker suggested that each trained pastor should have two or three mentees, and every theological graduate have one.
Extension Education has for long been regarded as a second-class citizen in the world of theological education. However, when people take their driving test, as one speaker pointed out, the only issue is whether they can drive, not where they learnt to drive nor who taught them. What matters is whether people can teach and minister Biblical Christian faith and practice. Ways of accrediting this need to be developed.
Much theological education in the Global South is supported not by their churches but by the West. This makes it vulnerable and already one government threatens to close any Christian institution receiving foreign funds. The challenge is for students to find resources and support from friends, family and local churches.
32
Transformational Theology and Theological Education in Africa, 20 October 2020 and Profiling Transformational Curricula on 30 November 2020 Dr Sas Conradie
About 100 leaders attended a webinar on 20 October 2020 to discuss 25 presentations on Transformational Theology and Theological Education in Africa. This was after a call for presentations on Transformational Theology and Theological Education in Africa. This was part of the journey in 2020 to facilitate discussion on a more contextual theology and theological education in Africa.
Some of the themes that participants engaged with include: ∙ Why Transformational Theology and Theological Education in Africa? ∙ Why African Transformational Theology?
∙ A framework for Transformational Theology in Africa.
∙ The Integral Mission Curriculum in Francophone Africa as example of contextual theological education in Africa.
∙ A missional ecclesiology as basis for transformed theological education.
∙ Transformational Theology and Theological Formation – perspectives from African Instituted Churches.
The intention was that theologians from across Africa share their perspectives on Transformational Theology and Theological Education in Africa. Despite serious technological challenges, the presentations generated lively discussion and enabled presenters to add new perspectives to their thinking and presentations. There was a strong feeling during the presentations that there is a disconnect in what is taught in theological education in Africa and the practical realities on the ground. Practical theological courses that speak to the context is therefore essential. There are specific contexts such as urban contexts that are neglected in theological courses. Webinar participants called for a reframing of the way we do theology in Africa from a wholistic perspective in which God’s incarnation at the centre. Colonial Theology enslaved people in Africa. Transformational Theology should set people free to live harmoniously. In essence, we need a theology with new clothes. The dichotomy between a Theology of Being vs a Theology of Doing was also mentioned as a challenge to theology and theological education in Africa. Theology and the style of theological education in Africa must be more communal because the style of learning in African culture is more communal. The discussions clearly indicated that both theology and theological education in Africa need to be transformed. The different presentations provided glimpses how best this could be done.
33
However, much more discussions and conversations are needed to facilitate change.
With the increased interest in Transformational Theology and Theological Education, Tearfund and OCRPL in collaboration with networks of networks of African theological institutions organised a webinar on 30 November to discuss curricula with a focus on transformational theology that could be used in theological institutions. 30 Participants discussed 4 examples of Transformational Theology Curricula that are being offered through theological institutions including:
∙ A curriculum to train Pentecostal leaders in Transformational Theology in Zambia.
∙ A Certificate in Theology and Sustainable Community Development provided through the Transformational Compassion Network in Kenya.
∙ Integrating integral mission and transformational theology into the curriculum of Instituto Superior de Teologia Evangélica no Lubango (ISTEL) in Angola.
∙ The ‘God’s heart for the Poor’ course at Wings of Eagle Bible International Bible College in Malawi.
The presentations of the curricula showed how various theological institutions, denominations and networks start to contextualize theology and theological education in Africa. These curricula could be used in other theological institutions as well and could motivate theological institutions to adapt their own curricula. The discussions showed the importance to engage with the curricula and refine the curricula so that it could better meet the needs of churches and communities in Africa. Further interaction with leaders of theological institutions to improve their curricula would therefore be essential. One suggestion was to discuss more theological curricula in 2021.
34
Thematic areas
Context
Theological education in Africa: Trends & issues
Dr David Tarus3
Virtual consultation on collaboration in theological education and training in Africa on 2 April 2020
1) Key points of presentation
a. What is ACTEA?
i. Association for Christian Theological Education in Africa ii. A project of the Association of Evangelicals in Africa (AEA) iii. Globally connected to International Council for Evangelical Theological Education (ICETE) and the World Evangelical Alliance (WEA)
iv. ACTEA renews theological schools in Africa: by promoting quality theological training through institutional reviews and academic recognition; by providing institutional support services and capacity-building forums for leaders and faculty of theological institutions; and by facilitating networking and cooperation among African theological institutions.
b. Trends:
The Church is growing in the Majority World but declining in the West
i. This is a known fact as attested by notable scholars such as Lamin Sanneh, Philip Jenkins, Kwame Bediako and others.
ii. There is a big demand for theological education in the Majority World. Churches are opening new schools/training centers. This might not be the case in the West where churches and theological colleges are closing shop.
Interest in non-traditional theological education
c. Schools are realizing that they need to be innovative in their TE because they are not getting students. Students are interested in non-formal, off-site, online/hybrid/blended theological education because these modes of delivery afford students the opportunity to work and study at the same time.
3 Dr David Tarus is the Executive Director of the Association for Christian Theological Education in Africa. He can be contacted at - actea.africa@gmail.com
35
d. Some students are interested in studying at extension campuses so as to be close to their work places and families; some are interested in evening and weekend classes.
e. Some students are not interested in full-time Christian ministry but would want to gain theological and biblical training in order to serve their communities better.
f. In many places, churches and their institutions strongly resist nontraditional TE. They are afraid of compromising quality, watering down spiritual formation of students, and enhancement of Christian character especially in younger students.
Interest in spiritual formation of students and faculty i. Institutions have realized that it is important to emphasize spiritual formation of students and faculty in addition to academic and ministerial formation. Spiritual formation happens in and outside the classroom. It also occurs through Christian service. Thus, some institutions emphasize these varied components of formation. Others still have a long way to go.
ii. “This is why the key institution in the church is the seminary or theological college. In every country the church is a reflection of its seminaries. All the church’s future pastors and teachers pass through a seminary. It is there that they are either made or marred, either equipped and inspired or ruined. Therefore, we should set ourselves to capture the seminaries of the world for evangelical faith, academic excellence and personal godliness. There is no better strategy for the reform and renewal of the church.” John Stott, The Message of Titus.
A mushrooming of institutions that have no interest in quality theological education
iii. There is a mushrooming of institutions especially from the Pentecostal and charismatic persuasions that have no interest and capacity for quality TE. Some of these institutions are training centers conducted inside the church or the pastor’s house. Most have no libraries and curriculums. Some import materials wholesale from the West. Some are degree mills.
36
iv. Is there a way we can help these new ‘institutions’?
Recognition for the need to train holistically
v. SKILLS TRAINING. Students need to be shaped in community development, leadership, public speaking, research, publishing, media, technology, social media, marketing, and other life skills. However, few institutions actually have such programs ingrained in their curriculum.
vi. CROSS-CULTURAL TRAINING: Institutions are aware of the need for cross-cultural training that goes beyond the traditional curriculum which only emphasized evangelism, discipleship, and mission outreach. We need to equip students for intercultural skills that include issues of national cohesion, conflict transformation, marketplace existence, public service, and community building.
vii. FORMING PROPHETS FOR THE SOCIETY: Institutions are desperately aware of the need to form their students to speak truth to power. They know that students need to engage in critical areas facing African societies such as materialism and corruption, sexuality, creation care, peace-making, urbanization, and interfaith relations. As to whether the institutions are actually equipped to successfully train students in this endeavor is debatable.
Seminaries transitioning to Liberal Arts/Christian Universities viii. We observe a trend among established theological institutions to shift to liberal arts orientation. Even those institutions that are yet to shift are longing for that shift even though they don’t have the capacity or resources. What are the reasons offered for transition? (Simon Mulatu, Transitioning from a Theological College to a Christian University)
ix. To build financial sustainability
x. To have a Christian influence in society by providing Christian higher education
xi. To be able to offer government-accredited degrees so that graduates can get jobs in governmental and non
governmental organizations
xii. To fulfill the church’s long-time vision of providing Christian education up to university level
37
xiii. To meet the growing need for trained leaders in churches in different areas (in addition to theological/pastoral ministry)
xiv. To meet the growing needs for higher education in the country
xv. Pressure from the government to get a charter/accreditation
xvi. To compete with other religious groups that have started their own universities.
1. The dangers of secularization. The loss of
religious distinctiveness; a revision of the
Christian mission statement of the college;
a more liberal admission as well as hiring
policies; a decline in Bible-centered
education; a decline in chapel services; the
institution abandons its strong connection
to the church etc.
g. Issues:
i. Seminary Sustainability
ii. Theological institutions do not have resources such as endowments, capital funds, legacy funds, etc. Thus, they cannot afford commercial rate like private universities, yet they are expected to deliver services of comparable quality. The reality is that “theological education in the majority world is more often economically not viable.”
iii. - Some institutions are not up to date in payments of salaries; some have cut on maintenance
iv. - How can the seminary be viable in the midst of overwhelming poverty? Will theological institutions survive Covid-19?
v. Ownership
vi. Many theological institutions in Africa operate like orphans. The stakeholders rarely have the enthusiasm to support, enrich, and resource their schools yet they claim ownership of them. This is called ‘deferred responsibility’ – stakeholders claim ownership but defer responsibility to institutional heads.
38
2) Governance
a. Several institutions struggle with councils that have no clue in governance of theological institutions. Some of them are there by virtue of their denominational leadership but do not have the knowhow or enthusiasm to assist the schools to move to the next level.
3) Leadership and Management
a. many seminary leaders have not always been trained in Executive leadership and its responsibilities. The work of leading a seminary is very demanding.
b. The faculty members are not adequately prepared for the various administrative tasks that are sometimes placed on their shoulders
c. We also see serious problems when it comes to leadership transitions.
4) Curriculum Development
a. Many curriculums in theological schools are outdated. They were developed by Western missionaries many years ago. Some curriculums have never been revised.
b. Others are imported wholesale from elsewhere. Some curriculums are not contextually relevant; some do not address current challenges that the students will experience when they graduate.
5) Accreditation and Affiliation
a. Accreditation and affiliation are still a major issue and problem for both mainline and other church-based and ecumenical theological institutions. Why the reluctance to be accredited?
a. Inadequate facilities such as
classrooms, library, etc
b. low enrolments
c. unqualified faculty
d. Financial challenges + some
colleges have no audit reports
2. Other colleges simply don’t want to go
through the rigorous process of
accreditation
3. Others don’t want to be accountable to an
external body
39
6) Main discussion points
7) Dr Tarus emphasised a number of trends and challenges a. Interest in non-traditional theological education
b. Theological institutions are not prepared for changes c. Spiritual and pastoral formation vs academic learning d. Whole person training
e. Quality theological education
f. Wholistically trained pastors in areas such as community development.
g. The transition to Liberal Arts universities.
8) Dr Tarus emphasised a number of issues
a. Most institutions are not financially sustainable.
b. Ownership of theological institutions
c. Curriculum development
d. Accreditation
9) Better mapping of theological institutions
10) Theological resources is a big challenge for institutions and students. a. Theological institutions use books that are outdated. b. Seminars for writers should be arranged.
c. Out of date electronic infrastructure and equipment. d. The NetACT internet portal could give access to theological resources.
e. NetACT is working on an online African Theological Journal. f. Langham Publishing provides grants of £100 per year to theological libraries to access books and £2,000 as larger grants..
g. Collaboration would be needed to create access to more resources.
11) Curriculum development
i. There is a big demand for pastors but pastoral
ministry is not attractive because of income of
pastors and the curriculum taught at theological
institutions.
ii. There is a high number of part-time pastors.
iii. Theological institutions need to revise their curriculum to meet the needs of churches. Qualified
teachers who can help with curriculum development
need to be identified.
40
iv. Revise curricula of institutions to decolonise theological education and equip pastors to address
the needs in their institutions.
v. Refresher and short courses could help to train pastors.
b. Accreditation is a key challenge
i. Accreditation is tilted towards academic
development and not ministerial formation
ii. Many theological institutions provide sub-standard of training. Well-established institutions could assist
smalled institutions.
iii. Greater collaboration is needed with the Commissions of Higher Education in the different
countries to accredit the curricula of theological
institutions. ACTEA could help to lobby
governments. MOU’s with the higher education
bodies of countries could help improve accrediting
theological institutions.
12) Conclusion and possible next steps
a. The following challenges and issues around theological education and training in Africa emerged:
i. Development and access to theological resources
ii. Development of contextualised curriculum and educational delivery
iii. Accreditation
iv. Engagement with various stakeholders in theological education
v. Financial sustainability.
b. There seems to be a need identify specialists who could assist with:
i. Accreditation.
ii. Resource development and distribution in various theological disciplines.
iii. Contextually relevant curriculum development and delivery.
iv. Networking to ensure that the various stakeholders are properly engaged.
41
c. There are various networks and organisations that can assist theological institutions in Africa dealing with specific challenges and issues:
i. Langham Publishing
ii. The Network for African Congregational Theology (NetACT) is developing an online resource portal
iii. The Association for Christian Theological Education in Africa (ACTEA) and the Le Conseil des Institutions Théologiques d’Afrique Francophone (CITAF) can help with accreditation advice.
iv. The Theological Commissions of the All Africa Conference of Churches (AACC), the Association for Evangelicals in Africa (AEA) and the Organization of African Instituted Churches (OAIC) can help with the engagement of various stakeholders in theological education and training.
v. Dr John Jusu can assist with curriculum development and educational delivery methods.
d. Collaborative working groups should be developed to address the key issues of accreditation, resource development, curriculum and educational development and networking.
42
Challenges facing the church and communities in Africa
Dr Richard Mutura4
Virtual consultation on collaboration in theological education and training in Africa on 2 April 2020
1) Presentation
a. Challenges facing the communities in Africa
i. A crisis of social-political leadership
1. Massive looting, corruption and mismanagement of public resources resulting in poverty and unemployment
2. Leadership crisis: unethical leadership; leaders not accountable to the electorate; voting leaders without ethics and integrity; political greed (protecting self-interest); overrepresentation and duplication of roles
3. Lack of accountability of political leaders to the electorate; abuse of power; Lack of trust
4. Disunity and lack of patriotism; Divisive politics; tribal Politics leading to post-election crises; Political parties lacking ideology; they are personal outfits to win elections; Cyclic violence (Negative ethnicity, Nepotism)
5. Corruption; Lack of value-driven leadership; Greed for power
6. Lack of civic engagement in holding government accountable due to apathy and lack of awareness; This leads to poor service delivery.
ii. Socio-cultural crisis
1. Disintegration of values; Lack/poor values; Lack of good role models; Increasing moral decadence (abortion, domestic violence, LGBTQ); Erosion of values and morals (corruption is symptomatic of this erosion; moral decadence);
2. Family breakdown: Divorce; Violence in the family; Lack of social cohesion; Moral decadence; Impunity); Dysfunctional families - as seen from difficulties with parenting, rise in adultery and divorce; Declining moral standards and respect for each other - drug/substance abuse; radicalization; gangs and goons.
4 Dr Richard Mutura is the Executive Director of the Community Transformation Centre in Nairobi. He can be contacted at richard.mutura@gmail.com
43
3. High levels of youth unemployment and social crimes; Youth bulge - energetic and vibrant youth population who are idle; Loss of identity due to urbanization leading to drug misuse, gambling/betting; Alternative Lifestyles); increasing violence.
4. Inequality and inadequate access to basic services, such as health care
5. Negative ethnicity; Lack of unity; people are divided along ethnic lines.
iii. Environmental/Climate change crisis
1. Weak public awareness on the importance of environmental conservation; Lack of stewardship of the natural resources 2. Pollution of the environment; Poor waste management, e.g. plastics; Air quality; Noise pollution - cars, industries, bars, churches, mosques; Garbage and waste management - plastics, landfills
3. Poor resource Management: wildlife-human conflicts; agricultural land used for construction; soil erosion; land grabbing; Agricultural land subdivision into unproductive land units; food insecurity.
4. Deforestation and loss of cover; Harvesting; massive loss of tree cover, extinction of indigenous trees, global warming; Cutting down trees; Not planting enough trees; Encroachment of forests, rivers, oceans;
5. Water use: lack of water harvesting; Inadequate measures of protection of water towers.
6. Manifesting itself in global warming.
iv. Technological crisis
1. Misuse of information technology and social media: redefinition of truth; dehumanization due to a false identity. 2. Growth of cyber-crime, bullying and terrorism Misuse of e government platforms
3. Growing addiction to betting
4. Pornography- increased access to porn content by the youth/adults
5. Cyber-attacks and identity theft
6. Use of fast internet for leisure rather than a means of earning an income
v. Legal/Justice crisis
44
1. Access to justice in sub-Saharan Africa is limited to due over commercialization,
2. Corruption in the courts, corrupt lawyers
3. A passive population unaware of, or unwilling to demand, its rights.
4. Why pay a lawyer when you can buy the judge? vi. Economic Crisis
1. Access to credit and capital limited to ordinary citizens 2. Misappropriation of public resources: massive looting; Bloated public wage bill; poor management of the economy; 3. Unemployment and underemployment, especially among the youth-who are majority Africans;
4. Lack of investment in productive sectors of the economy such as agriculture; lack of value addition; consumerism and most resources going into salaries at the expense of development; increasing the cost of doing business
5. Increasing national debt burden; living beyond the means/ mortgaging citizens
6. Increasing cost of living and poverty; Unequal distribution of resources; exploitation by the rich.
7. Emergence of new economic Ideas: Lending institutions that shy away from /lending to/ investing in startups.
Challenges facing the church in Africa
vii. Introduction
1. African is now the Headquarters of world Christianity 2. The church still commands great trust from the populace and goodwill from the governments across Africa
3. Going by its numbers and grassroots networks, the church has the greatest potential to influence the continent 4. The Church has the greatest concentration of young people and professionals in its ranks.
viii. A unity crisis
1. The church is not united enough to have a common voice 2. Denominations and umbrella bodies that are exclusive rather than inclusive
3. Ethnic divisions
45
4. Lack of grassroots mobilisation and advocacy approaches, including movement building, that could ultimately lead to lasting positive governmental and societal changes ix. Leadership crisis
1. The church has allowed itself to struggle with the same ills as the rest of the society, such as corruption, ethnicity, and greed amongst its leaders.
2. Obsession with wealth and riches by majority clergy 3. Manipulative and coercive where necessary
4. Church lead by pastors struggling with personal failures in education (Majority primary school dropouts
5. Attracted to power and building alliances with politicians as a means to access power
6. Leadership transition crisis - Not plans for retirement for old clergy or term limits for bishops
a. Kenya example (Evangelical bishops due for retirement)
b. Nigeria –Government interventions to manage church transition
x. Relevance and prophetic voice in the nation 1. Church was seen as being silent or complicit to the issues of the day and did not seem to know how to be salt and light in the affairs of the nation.
2. Dwindling prophetic voice
3. The face of Christianity in public square is the non-trained theologians shaping community perspectives on the gospel of Jesus Christ
4. Training and curricula that does not empower the church to address the pressing needs in their context
5. Lack of coordinated strategic support to churches to come together to speak out on issues facing the nation 6. Inadequate refresher courses for serving pastors in holistic ministry, and production of materials for Bible study with a transformation lens for use by churches
xi. Relevancy of theological education
1. Limiting proclamation, conversation and discipleship to pulpits within the church spaces and occasional organized outreaches
2. Absolute curricula/dated curriculum
46
3. Lack of strategic engagements with Christian professionals in the marketplace-as career missionaries in their own contexts and countries
4. New frontiers for the kingdom advancement
5. Strong Theology of the church but weak Theology of the Kingdom
xii. Lack of capacity to hold governments to account for provision of services
1. Non-existent or inadequate Training of clergy to understand processes of government so that they can hold them accountable in the implementations of plans and provision of services
2. This would help the clergy and members demand for better services
3. Public participation in bills and fiscal papers
xiii. Economic Crisis to resourcing the Kingdom
1. Church that is unable to step up and unlock its own resources according to the Biblical mandate of addressing poverty through the practical interpretation of faith; as well as a prophetic call for equity and justice.
2. Releasing resources to promote the cause of the gospel beyond the church premises
3. Business models that serve individual needs and not the kingdom needs
xiv. Discipleship crisis
1. The church that is able to attract but not able to disciple those who come to mature in faith
2. We can account for Christians on Sunday morning but we cannot account for their influence Monday to Saturday 3. Gathered church and scattered church
b. Conclusion
i. There is an urgent need for a theological training curriculum that empowers the clergy to serve the serve the church, the community and the nation without any tension
ii. This curriculum should be instrumental in the formation of a pastor as a public servant, a prophet, a teacher, a preacher, a community religious leader, a social worker and a leadership coach
47
iii. To attain similar orientation and formation, there is need to develop productive collaborative partnerships between theological umbrella bodies, theological institutions and Christian organizations to create synergy in curriculum review and development of a common pool of resources for training and capacity building.
2) Main discussion points
a. The challenges facing the church and communities in Africa is the context in which pastors and church leaders are trained and should be trained for.
b. A crisis of hope and faith – people lose faith in leaders, including theological leaders
c. Crisis of leadership that is leading to poverty. Leaders are not accountable. Citizens are not engaged
d. Disunity and patriotism; tribalism leading to power control e. Collaboration in transformative curriculum in which the context is taken into account is needed
f. The socio-cultural crisis is a crisis of values
g. There is a lack of awareness of environmental issues. Resources are not managed well
h. Additional issues not mentioned in the presentation i. Legacy of colonialism
ii. Endemic poverty
iii. Weak states resulting in refugees
i. There is a question of ownership of theological education, including the hermeneutical and homiletical foundations j. Many pastors have little education – that makes theological education challenging
k. Dualism in Christianity in Africa is a problem. Though African traditional culture is wholistic, Christians separate Christian life from public life.
l. Negative analysis is due to the enormity of challenges facing communities, but also the request to focus on these issues. We need to craft models of theological training in response to these challenges. Theological leaders need to provide thought leadership to the church in addressing those challenges. If the church would not engage with those challenges they will leave the church. Some of them might even decide to become Muslims.
48
m. Theological leaders need to show a kind of engagement with the challenges so that Africa will be different.
n. We need to address family issues more in theological education and develop a curriculum that encourages African ways of modelling families.
o. Churches are ill prepared for contemporary issues. We should adapt our curricula accordingly. But what should such curricula look like?
p. Spiritual formation is essential in theological education. But it has to be relevant. We should emphasise the priesthood of all believers and look at equipping ministers for the workplace.
q. People taking a theological degree is a calling and not to make money. However, because of the economic challenges, we start to get second career pastors in especially urban churches. This is also to engage better with the marketplace.
3) Conclusion and possible next steps
a. There is a clear need to address specific challenges in communities and churches in which pastors and church leaders are trained and should be trained for.
i. Leadership crisis
ii. Socio-cultural issues, including values and practices
iii. Economic issues and especially poverty
iv. Spiritual challenges as reflected in discipleship, increased secularism and religious radicalism
v. Environmental
vi. Weak states as reflected in lack of political and other areas of accountability
b. Models of theological training, including spiritual formation, should be developed to equip leaders deal with these challenges.
c. The picture is not totally negative. There are also many opportunities for theological education including the growth of the church in Africa, the role of the church in African society and the rich cultural heritage that theological leaders can tap into for pedagogy and content.
d. Next steps
i. Identify how are issues presently addressed by the
theological education and training.
49
ii. Identify resources that can help theological institutions and training initiatives deal with the issues and opportunities.
iii. Consider forming working groups around those issues and opportunities that could look at curriculum development and training.
50
The possibilities of collaboration in online theological education in a digital Africa
Dr Nico Mostert5
Virtual conference of leaders of theological colleges and seminaries in Africa, 9 September 2020
1) Obstacles in institutional collaboration
a. “One of the significant difficulties faced in inter organizational collaboration is the conflict between an existing collective identity, formed with formerly autonomous organizations, and the need for a new collective identity involving interdependent organizations working towards mutual goals”. (Mandell, Keast, Chamberlain, 2016)
b. Theological differences (Dogma) Denominational preferences Access to resources (internet connectivity) Unspoken “superiority” (bigger and smaller institutions) Strong historical identities (church/denomination and institutional)
2) New realities
a. Covid-19
b. Global world connected via internet
c. Global economic decline
d. Poverty among African churches
e. Rising cost of higher education (moving to or expanding online teaching)
f. Rising of African academia
g. Bringing African knowledge to the world platform
h. Access to and cost of on knowledge on the global platform 3) A way out: Collaboration?/!
a. “the action of working with someone to produce something” b. How to start?
i. “Conversation and language are the tools through
which these new collective identities are negotiated,
5 Dr Nico Mostert is the Coordinator of the Network for African Congregational Theology (NetACT). He can be contacted at missio@ngkvs.co.za
51
and successful collaboration is achieved”. (Mandell, Keast, Chamberlain, 2016)
c. Types/models of collaboration (theory) - cooperative, coordinative, and collaborative (Keast, Brown and Mandell, 2007).
i. Cooperative networks
1. The key elements: establishment of short-term collaboration, often informal and largely voluntary relations between organizational entities (Lawson, 2002)
2. In cooperative relationships, participants may agree to share information, office space (curriculum “gaps” or shortages) or referrals; however, no effort is made to establish common goals, and each agency remains separate, retaining autonomy and its own resources (Winer and Ray, 1994; Cigler, 2001)
3. As a process, cooperation is essentially about taking others into consideration, compromising, and being accommodating, without
necessarily adjusting individual goals.
4. Given that cooperation entails the use of very few resources, mainly information sharing, it is further characterized by low levels of
intensity and risk and tends to be a less strategic operation (Whetten, 1977; Winer and
Ray, 1994; Cigler, 2001).
ii. Coordinative networks
1. occur when there is a need to better align or orchestrate people, tasks, and resources to achieve a predetermined goal (better theological education across Africa, NetACT, ACTEA etc)
2. Coordination requires more than information sharing; it is involved with joint planning and policy, decision-making, and actions between organizations.
3. While it draws on mechanisms that more tightly and formally link organizations together, they remain separate from each other
(Alter and Hage, 1993).
52
iii. Collaborative networks
1. In a collaborative network there is reciprocal interdependence—there is an understanding that “they cannot meet their interests working alone and that they share with others a common problem” (Innes and Booher, 2000: 7)
2. For a collaborative networks to succeed the following factors needs to be considered:
a. Institutional factors – Resources, structure, willingness to change b. Relationship factors – communication, commitment, trust, culture (denominational and institutional)
c. Output factors – objectives, be sure of one’s own needs and requirements, knowledge and technology transfer
d. Framework factors – environment (context), respect for contracts and intellectual property rights (Rybnicek and Königsgruber, 2018)
4) In conclusion
a. No “one size fits all”
b. We have in Africa numerous good networks (and they in turn are networking)
c. There is a movement towards conversation between all and a “new” language is taking shape
d. We have different models which can be used to suit your institutions needs
e. Fact is: it will become increasingly difficult to “make it on your own” , sustainability is connected to collaboration
5) Questions for small group discussions
a. Share your institutions experience (if any) with collaborations with other institutions?
b. What is/was the benefits for your institution within collaborations?
c. What “best practices” have you discovered that contributes towards better collaborations with other institutions?
d. What are the hindrances that makes collaborations with other institutions difficult?
53
Sustainability Lessons from African Christian College’s Tree of Life Project Shared during the virtual conference of leaders of theological colleges and seminaries in Africa, 9 September 2020
sustainability - the ability to secure stable and sufficient long-term financial resources, and to allocate them in a timely manner and appropriate form, to cover the full costs of the organization.
THE TREE OF LIFE STORY
The first students of Manzini Bible School in Eswatini began their training in 1967. Primarily supported by a USA congregation, the school and its farmland survived, but struggled. By 1995, the supporters were ready to sell the property and close the school but one leader maintained hope. His efforts, with the help of many others, led to the development of the Tree of Life Project — a macadamia orchard on the campus property — in 1997 to become a “living” financial endowment for the school.
Many macadamia trees have been planted since the first seedlings. Significant resources have been spent on growing, caring, and maintaining the orchard of over 14,000 trees. As the orchard has grown, so has the school. Brought under the oversight of a board of trustees in 2007, the school changed its name to African Christian College and cast a vision as a Christian higher education institution. It continues to grow and seek ways to best serve the changing church in Africa. ACC is one of only 3 recognized private higher learning institutions in Eswatini and its Bachelor of Theology degree is accredited by ACTEA.
Today, the orchard provides work to a dozen full-time employees, a two dozen temporary employees, and over fifty students. Today, revenue from the macadamia nut orchards on campus provide between 75-100% of the college’s operational costs in Eswatini.
CHOOSING MACADAMIAS
African Christian College had 200 acres of land that hadn’t been cultivated in over 20 years. A missionary farmer began a farm on the property in 1968, but had two years of mild success. The land remained untilled until 1996 as plans to rent the land for farming began. However, a South African Christian farmer who was converting his land into a macadamia orchard, gathered soil and weather data from campus, and recommended the college grow macadamias,
54
too. Money was raised for the project — first at Africans Claiming Africa in 1997 — from African and USA congregations and, with the help of this new orchard farmer, the Tree of Life Project was born.
Macadamia growing was just becoming popular in Southern Africa. African Christian College’s campus was suitable in size, shape, weather, and resources for this new export crop. Today, Southern Africa is the world’s leading producer of macadamia nuts. Most of African Christian College’s macadamia nuts are sold directly to a high-end grocery chain called HEB Central Market in Texas, USA.
FACING CHALLENGES
The Tree of Life has been filled with challenges, mistakes, and new problems arise regularly. The biggest challenge came on 11 Sept 2001 when an early morning fire killed over 400 trees and devastated the orchard.
Mistakenly, the grass between trees had been allowed to grow uncut becoming a wick for the fire to quickly spread all the way down a row. The farm was not equipped with access points for water nor fire-fighting equipment to put out the fire. Today, the orchard is mowed, fire breaks are burned, has multiple water access points and a fire cart.
Other mistakes include securing inadequate equipment, poor planning, and polluted water sources. These mistakes reduce the ability to harvest usable nuts for earning revenue. Now, the leadership utilizes the services of certified macadamia experts, replaces equipment, fixes what can be fixed, and tries to plan carefully to reduce negative consequences.
ENSURING ONGOING SUCCESS
Managing an orchard of 14,000 trees is no small task. It requires year-round attention. The orchard staff works daily fertilizing, watering, harvesting and pruning trees to ensure a healthy, plentiful harvest. They also work repairing equipment, keeping bees, maintaining finances, and working with partners in cracking, roasting, packaging, and delivering nuts.
The college invests in the development of the Tree of Life staff to improve their performance. This includes attending workshops, participating in macadamia nut associations, hosting fire-fighting lessons, and providing learning materials
55
to increase success. We evaluate employees, products, equipment and methods to improve our annual harvest.
MAKING AN IMPACT IN THE KINGDOM OF GOD
The Tree of Life Project doesn’t exist simply as a business to make money. It is a business of African Christian College and a tool to accomplish the mission to glorify God by equipping students for excellent service in God’s Kingdom. Increasing and maintaining income from the Tree of Life project is part of African Christian College’s sustainability plan. The college grows much of the food served in its cafeteria, seeks payment from students and maintains relationships with donors and potential donors. An investment in the success of the Tree of Life Project is an investment in the college’s mission. The growing, harvesting, processing, roasting and sale of macadamia nuts leads to African Christian College’s ability today and in the future to prepare visionary leaders to serve, grow, and strengthen the church in Africa.
SUSTAINABILITY LESSONS
1) SECURE LOCAL RESOURCES BEFORE IT’S TOO LATE - Churches and mission organizations should seek stable and sufficient long-term financial resources from local sources before the threat of losing
2) USE YOUR ASSETS - Identify resources (expertise, land, labor, time) you already have and find ways to use it for producing revenue. 3) DO WHAT WORKS - Find things that earn money and are needed in your community.
4) PLAN CAREFULLY - Before embarking on a major project, research to find the best methods for success. In some cases, it is necessary to find a true expert to help with planning.
5) PREPARE FOR THREATS - The unexpected can happen, but many costly mistakes can be avoided by preparing for them ahead of time. 6) INVEST IN SUCCESS - Successful ventures require equipped staff, adequate tools, and commitment from the leadership.
7) EVALUATE + IMPROVE - Look for ways to improve efficiency, increase income and reduce costs.
8) REMEMBER THE MISSION - Don’t forget the reason sustainability efforts exist: to continue growing the Kingdom of God.
African Christian College - www.AfricanChristianCollege.org ACC@AfricanChristianCollege.org
56
Thematic areas
Transformational Theology and Theological Education
Transformation From Within
Prof. Patrick Sookhdeo6
Webinar on Transformational Theology and Theological Education in Africa, 20 October 2020
Introduction
Yesterday we heard from Msgr. Indunil J. Kodithuwakku of Pope Benedict XVI’s comment in his encyclical Spe Salvi that
“Christianity did not bring a message of social revolution like that of the ill-fated Spartacus. […] Jesus was not Spartacus; he was not engaged in a fight for political liberation like Barabbas or Bar- Kochba.” They used violence in attempting to overthrow unjust and repressive political rulers and systems. Instead, Pope Benedict XVI adds that “Jesus who himself died on the Cross brought an encounter with the living God and thus an encounter with a hope stronger than the sufferings of slavery, a hope which therefore transformed life and the world from within” (Spe Salvi n.4).7
As Pope Benedict pointed out, hope is essential for human life. Without hope, there is no will to live. Every human needs hopes, whether great or small, to motivate us. As Christians we have the greatest of all hopes, the Biblical hope of the Kingdom of God, which is not only the hope of heaven, but also the hope to see Christ reigning wherever He is loved. Yet, for many the hope of the Kingdom of God has been displaced by a hope for the “kingdom of man”, a humanistic hope of a better world, perhaps to be achieved by social revolution, even by the violent overthrow of unjust rulers and repressive systems. The hope of the “kingdom of man” is a hope that is constantly receding, but the hope of the Kingdom of God is a hope that transcends suffering and transforms life from within and thus enables us to engage the world.
6 Prof Patrick Sookhdeo is International Director of Barnabas Fund (https://barnabasfund.org). 7 Msgr. Indunil J. Kodithukwakku K.,“Interreligious Dialogue in the Catholic Church Since the Vatican Council II: An Evaluation” Public Lecture, Oxford Centre for Religion and Public Life, 19 October 2020.
57
In the context of this transformation of life from within, I would like us to consider today the New Testament Greek word nous (νοῦς) and how it impacts on our Christian belonging and identity both as individuals and as a community and the effects this has on the world.
With the pronunciation “nowse”, this word has become a British slang term meaning common sense, good judgement, practical intellect. But originally in Greek it meant reason, the universal mind, the force that brought the world into being.8
But what does nous mean in a Christian context? For the Protestant understanding, I will quote Strong’s Concordance:
3563 noús (a masculine noun) – the God-given capacity of each person to think (reason); the mind; mental capacity to exercise reflective thinking. For the believer, (noús) is the organ of receiving God's thoughts, through faith.
However, the Eastern Orthodox churches understand nous as having a far deeper meaning than simply the intellectual mind used for thinking and reasoning. In Orthodox Christianity, the nous is described as “the eye of the soul”, meaning the heart or the centre of our being, where true (i.e. spiritual) knowledge is recognised. Orthodox Christianity teaches that God created humankind with both intelligence and nous as well as with sensory perceptions that would include the spiritual realm.
1. Transformation involves the remoulding of our inner being Transformation must begin with a transformation of each of us, as individuals - a transformation of our inner being. We are told in Romans 12:2 “Do not be conformed to this world.” In JB Phillips’ famous translation: “Don’t let the world around you squeeze you into its own mould.” The Greek word for being conformed is suschematizesthai, based on the root schema, meaning an individual’s outward form, which is continually varying, like passing fashions.
8 Western tradition created a dichotomy between the mind and the heart, mind being the centre of reason and heart being the centre of emotion. It is interesting to note the difference in Chinese thought, for “the ‘heart’ and the ‘mind’, in their Western senses, are conceptualized in ancient Chinese philosophy as being one, the xin ‘heart,’ which houses thoughts and feelings, ideas and emotions. The Chinese heart is the core of affective and cognitive structure, conceived of as having the capacity for logical reasoning, rational understanding, moral will, intuitive imagination, and aesthetic feeling, unifying human will, desire, emotion, intuition, reason and thought.” Ning Yu, “Heart and Cognition in Ancient Chinese Philosophy”, Journal of Cognition and Culture, Vol. 7 (March 2007) p.28.
58
Paul is commanding us not to try to follow the ways of the world, like a chameleon that changes colour to match its surroundings.
The world, in this verse, is all that stands against God, whether ideas, ideologies, spiritual principalities and powers, demonic forces. The world is controlled by Satan. After the Fall, he took control of our minds and made them dark, deceitful, dishonest and destructive. For some, the mind is therefore a place of great terror, as depicted vividly in a poem by Gerard Manley Hopkins (1844-1889):
O the mind, mind has mountains; cliffs of fall
Frightful, sheer, no-man-fathomed.9
This is what Milton described as the mind making a hell of heaven, although equally the mind can make a heaven of hell.
… A mind not to be chang'd by Place or Time.
The mind is its own place, and in it self
Can make a Heav'n of Hell, a Hell of Heav'n.10
Instead of conforming to the world, we must be transformed by the renewing of our nous, which is translated as our “mind” or “thinking” in most English versions of the Bible. The word translated “transformed” is metamorphusthai, based on the root morphe, meaning the essential and unchanging aspect of something – in Platonic thought the “real”. Our schema will change considerably as we move from childhood to old age, but our morphe remains the same, as we are still the same person … until we commit our lives to following Christ. Then we must undergo a profound transformational inner change, affecting our morphe. This change renews our nous, for which we now see the English word “mind” is very inadequate. Perhaps the Jubilee Bible gets closer to the meaning with its use of the word “soul”.
It is clear Paul cannot be saying that merely a change in our intellect, reasoning and common sense is what should follow when we give our lives to the Lord. What must change is the “eye of the soul”, that which governs the body and directs all its parts, as well as governing our thoughts and wills. The nous is the seat of this governance, directing our wills, passions, desires, attitudes, ambitions, even the movements of the body.
9 Gerard Manley Hopkins, “No worst, there is none. Pitched past pitch of grief” 10 John Milton, Paradise Lost, lines 221-270
59
As we have seen, the world lies in the hands of the evil one. But a Christian’s nous, the control centre of their whole being, is focused on God and a process of transformation is taking place, as each believer’s nous is gradually renewed and purified, making us into the likeness of Christ.
This transformation process is boldly described in Orthodox Christianity as theosis, literally deification, “a never-ending growth, a process, an ascent toward God”, 11 whose purpose is to achieve unending union with God. This aim can never be achieved in this life, or even the next, and yet the process of transformation in this direction, the quest to become more and more like God, must continue and never be abandoned.
2. Transformation involves a radical change
At the Fall, Satan entered Eden and darkness ensued. The human nous became corrupted. It lost its spiritual anchor, focus and direction, and is now orientated towards evil. God is no longer the master of man. Man thinks he is his own master, but is in fact the slave of sin and Satan.
This is the situation that Paul describes in Ephesians 4:17-18 as walking in the futility of our nous and having our dianoia darkened, alienated from the life of God. The Greek word dianoia, translated “understanding”, is derived from nous and means the function of the nous (in the same way as seeing is the function of the eye).
In verses 23-24, Paul commands: “Be renewed in the spirit of your nous and put on the new man which was created according to God in true righteousness and holiness.” At conversion, Satan’s hold over us is broken, but the journey of sanctification that we then begin is a gradual process, a process of purification, with the end of Godlikeness, of Christlikeness.
3. Application
As individual Christians, we are now in the process of developing in Christlikeness, of growing in purification, sanctification and holiness as our lives are re-orientated Godward. All our attitudes, all our ambitions, are now a new creation. This has huge implications:
11 Hieromonk Damascene, “The Way of Spiritual Transformation”, a talk given at the Parish Life Conference of the Antiochian Orthodox Diocese of Wichita and Mid-America, Sioux City, Iowa, June 9, 2005.
60
a) We are no longer our own, for we belong to Christ. Our identity is that of Christ. Our first and primary identity is no longer that of our human family, that of our tribe, that of our ethnicity, or that of our nation. Our first and primary identity is that we belong to Christ. The Christian brotherhood, adelphoi, means literally to be born in the womb of Christ, of Jesus. Therefore we are all blood brothers.
When the Chinese government ordered that churches should carry the Chinese flag, many Christians objected. They thought this was Chinese political and nationalistic interference in the Church, showing the Christians submitted to the Chinese state. But what of the American flag in many American churches church or the British Union Jack flag in British churches? If the flag speaks of identity and loyalty, then should we have it in our churches, for Christians do not owe their first allegiance to a national entity, culture or identity, but rather it is Christ to whom they belong.
b) Having recognised this primary identity, there can be no racism or sexism within the Church or within the lives of individual Christians. One of the insults faced by the early Church was to be called the “third race”, and yet this hostile comment, as recorded by Tertullian, contains a wonderful spiritual truth.12
c) The individual Christian is now a part of a whole. As Paul writes, we are the Body of Christ and every individual Christian is a part of that Body. Each of us is of value, of worth and of status. Therefore, the Christian community, the Church, must now be in a process of transformation, just as each of her individual members is. The Church as a whole must reflect Jesus, must be that city set on a hill, that light which will cause all humankind to praise our heavenly Father (Matthew 5:14-16).
If one part of that body suffers the whole body suffers. So Christians should care especially for each other’s needs (Galatians
12 Tertullian, Ad Nationes, volume 1, chapter 8, translated by Q. Howe, in conjunction with the Patristics Project at Faulkner University.
http://www.faulkner.edu/academics/artsandsciences/humanities/patristics.asp ; http://www.tertullian.org/articles/howe_adnationes1.htm [accessed 18 October 2020].
61
6:10). The early Christian community was remarkable for this, as the New Testament records, with the disciples in Jerusalem having everything in common (Acts 2:44-45), and later substantial offerings being taken up by churches in Macedonia and Corinth for example (2 Corinthians 8).
The generous care of the early Church for those in need around them was one of the reasons that people were attracted to the Christian faith. They took seriously the value and worth of every human life. Sharing material goods and caring for others, for example nursing the sick during an epidemic, was a highly emphasised part of discipleship in the early Church and was duly noted by them13 and by those around them – not always approvingly:
It is disgraceful that, when no Jew ever had to beg,
and the impious Galileans [Christians] support not
only their own poor but ours as well, all men see that
our people [pagans] lack aid from us.14
These characteristics, which are the marks of a Christian growing in Christlikeness, must also be the marks of a Christian community. So the Christian community, the Church, should display selflessness, not materialism, status, wealth or power (Philippians 2:5-8). The Church must be emptied of any pride or nationalism. This transformed community now engages the principalities and powers of the world. The selfless, sacrificial love that shapes the individual Christian must be embodied in their Christian community, and extended to the world. This love by the transformed Christian community crosses all geographical, all racial, all cultural, all manmade barriers.
13 Takanori Inoue, “The Early Church’s Approach to the Poor in Society and Its Significance to the Church’s Social Engagement Today”, Asbury Theological Seminary, 2017, pp.6-11 https://place.asburyseminary.edu/firstfruitspapers/74/ [accessed 19 October 2020] 14 The Roman Emperor Julian (reigned 360-363, known to the Church as “Julian the Apostate” because he rejected Christianity) writing to a pagan priest, Epistles, 22. 430D, quoted in Binger A. Pearson, The Emergence of the Christian Religion: Essays on Early Christianity (Harrisburg, PA: Trinity Press International, 1997), p.211.
62
Indeed, it not only crosses these barriers, it shatters them. For the old creation fell into moral corruption, darkness, death and destruction. But the new creation has a new nous, in which the understanding is enlightened, darkness is banished, moral and spiritual corruption give way to purity and holiness, death gives way to life, and destruction ushers in a new creation.
Conclusion
God created us in His divine image with dignity, worth and value. We see in each human being the imago dei. In this journey towards perfection, in becoming more Godlike, we take on the attributes of our God, the infinitely perfect One. God has made us in His image and to reflect is purposes.
He is the Rock, His work is
perfect:
For all His ways are justice,
A God of truth and without injustice;
Righteous and upright is He.
(Deuteronomy 32:4 NKJV)
It is the three characteristics of God described in this verse – truth, justice and righteousness – that now shape us, both in our dealing with each other as Christians and in our dealings with the world around us that is under the control of the evil one. To this world, we must show the reality of truth, we must practise justice with mercy, and we must exhibit the moral characteristics of righteousness. Our engagement with the world will result in hostility and rejection (John 15:18-19) but it is a mission from which we cannot turn away. As Jesus our Lord engaged with the weak and the vulnerable, the sick and the lame; as He knew powerlessness, human frailty and human poverty, having nowhere to lay His head, so, as Christians, we show to the world this other life, this other realmnot because we teach it but because we live it. We are shaped by the life of Jesus incarnate, in His love and compassion, as we live in our dark and hostile world.
This calling will lead us to seek to address the injustices and abuses of our day, in whatever form they take, and to be faithful stewards of God’s creation. It will point to a true way of living and of being, and it will extend its compassion to those who are in need. Every culture, every individual has its particular weaknesses. The challenge of the Church of Jesus Christ today is to know which
63
aspects of a prevailing culture, based on its history and its values, must particularly be transformed. It is easy to recognise the weaknesses in other people’s cultures but hard to recognise them in one’s own.
This has always been the way of Christ and must ever be our way, the road that we take, the life that we live. The transformation from within that issues in the transformation of a Christian community will result in the healing of a suffering and broken world.
64
Rethinking Transformational Theology as a foundation for theological education
Dr Chris Sugden15
Webinar on Transformational Theology and Theological Education in Africa, 20 October 2020
1) Introduction
I have been asked to begin with a reflection on my own experience of teaching transformational theology in theological education.
My wife and I were invited to move to India to take up a post at a seminary in 1977 to teach ethics and modern theology. I had completed research in 1973 on A Christian Approach to Violence and Revolution. I had studied Liberation Theology, especially Gustavo Gutierrez’s recently published work Theology of Liberation. I did not accept his Marxist analysis of society but found his biblical insights very helpful. I also read Jesus and the Kingdom by George Eldon Ladd and Ron Sider’s Rich Christians in an Age of Hunger. The Lausanne Congress of 1974 published an appendix on Radical Discipleship. I introduced their insights on evangelism and social actions to the students. Shortly after we arrived a cyclone hit the East Coast of India devastating hundred’s of villages. I could not in conscience teach students about social concern and do nothing about this so took a team of students over the Christmas holiday to assist a relief agency with the clear up work in some villages.
After six months during Lent 1978 I was called to see the principal and in essence told that my teaching was causing problems for the seminary with some of the American donors. We would therefore have to take a break. We did so and the Lord called us to other ministry with Dr Vinay Samuel. But I do not regret that six months, painful as the outcome was since the students I was privileged to teach have gone on to lead significant holistic ministries in India and South East Asia.
Following our departure from the seminary Dr Vinay Samuel asked me to work with him in Theological Education by Extension. We created
15 Dr Chris Sugden is Co-Dean of the Oxford Centre for Religion and Public Life.
65
three courses related to wholistic ministry for lay people between 1978-1982: Jesus the Liberator, Poverty and Development and Working Together for Health. These courses involved participants in exposure to those living in poor conditions and engaging in action. From there Dr Vinay and other leaders from the Global South developed post-graduate theological education by extension through the Oxford Centre for Mission Studies where people with significant experience in ministry did Masters and Doctoral work on aspects of holistic ministry for transformation in their communities. This is now continuing in the partnership of OCRPL with Barnabas Fund.
I will outline four pillars of transformational theology and note that while a holistic theology is a necessary foundation for bringing transformation to a community it is not sufficient.
2) The Biblical Pillars of transformational theology
a. New identity
My own doctoral research on the work of Dr Vinay and Mrs Colleen Samuel among poor people in Bangalore, on innovative enterprise development work in India and Indonesia, and recent exhaustive research on new communities of Christians among Dalits (outcastes) in South India by Dr Rebecca Shah, have shown that the main impact of exposure to the Christian gospel for poor, vulnerable and marginalised people is that having been treated as nobodies by the rest of society and the wider community, they find that in Jesus they become somebodies, sons and daughters of the creator and lord of creation.
This new identity gives them a sense of dignity and worth that had been denied them. This opens up new views of who they and their families were, what they could do and what they could become. This will contribute to people being able to change their mindset, which has been identified as a most important factor in addressing their situation.
We see this theme of a new identity throughout the scripture: If anyone is in Christ he/she is a new creation
You must be born again
Citizens of the kingdom
66
Sons and daughters of God
New identity is because through the death and resurrection of Jesus, the second Adam, we are born into the new creation which is the second pillar
b. Kingdom of God
The synoptic gospels all introduce the ministry of Jesus in the same way: He came into Galilee preaching the good news of the kingdom of God. The Jews were looking for this kingdom, the new heavens and new earth foretold for example by Isaiah.
Jesus announced that the kingdom was present in his person and ministry even while this earth still stood. His ministry exemplified the life of the kingdom - through his healings, through his mastery of the created order, and through creating a new community of the kingdom of those who were born again.
The major point here is that the life and impact of the kingdom extends to the whole created order. Thus its impact is to be seen here and now over all aspects of life.
This good news of this kingdom, Jesus said was especially Good News to the Poor. To those with a new identity as members of the kingdom the kingdom offers the hope that God has a purpose which can be seen already in this world and which will be fulfilled when the kingdom comes in all its fulness. The good news of the kingdom brings a new identity and hope.
This is a third pillar of transformational theology.
c. Good news to poor
The poor in scripture means those who are economically or socially poor and marginalised. In the Beatitudes we read Blessed are the poor in spirit as well as blessed are the poor. What this means is those who have an attitude to God which characterizes poor people, dependence on God, because they cannot depend on others or even themselves. Poor in spirit does not mean those
67
who are spiritually poor or dead in sin, but those whose attitude to God is the same as that of those who are poor.
There are qualitative and quantitative definitions of the poor. The reference is not purely materialistic but includes those who are vulnerable, whom as Dr Vinay Samuel has said, literally live on a precipice and very near to falling off. Such are those who depend on daily wages and have lost their jobs in the current covid pandemic.
This teaching shows that what the gospel means to those who are really poor who receive it is to define what it means for everyone else. We are called to bring the good news of the kingdom of God to the poor.
What then is the goal of Christian ministry with the poor?
d. That people may be stewards of creation.
This is a fourth pillar of transformational theology. God’s purpose for humanity was to be the image of God. Images in the Ancient Near East were the representatives of the absentee God and ruler of the land. The Genesis account affirms that the image and representative of the invisible landlord of the land is not an idol or statue, but every man and woman. Every man and woman has the role of representing God and caring for the world he made.
So our purpose is to enable men and women to fulfil their calling as stewards of creation. One ministry that has taken this forward is that of micro-enterprise development, enabling people to begin their own businesses with small loans and as part of a supportive group.
This is an expression of justice.
3) These biblical pillars underpin the role of the church The church is called to be an outpost of the kingdom of God which will one day transform the whole world into the new heavens and earth when Jesus returns. It is to show in this order of creation what a transformed world would look like. It is to show the love of Christ
68
which Augustine described as follows in answer to the question: “What does love look like? It has the hands to help others. It has the feet to hasten to the poor and needy. It has eyes to see misery and want. It has the ears to hear the sighs and sorrows of men. That is what love looks like.”
To do this the church needs to engage with local community in which it is set.
As it shares the good news of the kingdom through word and deed it holds out a new identity to the poor and vulnerable, it demonstrates the work of the kingdom to transform all areas of life, it seeks to enable people to fulfil their calling to be the stewards of creation.
There are many ways to do this. One that has recently been pointed out is that especially among communities of the poor there are not enough skills or resources to do this. So the church can train people in the skills they need, and where appropriate for any large scale project that is needed to engage with partners in the nation who can bring larger scale resources. This may well be businessmen at the national level or the government.
4) Changing not only the content of the curriculum but the way training takes place
Such theology is necessary but it is not sufficient to bring about transformation in a community.
Theological education should enable people, both those training for full time ministry and lay people to experience for themselves good examples of the church’s involvement in transforming communities. The training will then enable them to reflect on these in the light of the Bible.
So our theological education will need to include exposure visits to situations of need and where Christians are ministering to those needs; placements of trainees for short of long periods in such ministries; and also hands on work experience. This experience must then be a resource for reflection in the light of the scripture, which will
69
illuminate the experience and also open up fresh understanding of the biblical material.
5) Imparting skills in engaging with other communities - business/ government
Many Christians are involved now in ‘development’ and ‘social action’ with agencies. It is important that they are equipped to insist religion is important for the total development of people and take seriously the spiritual reality, encouraging them to draw on whatever spiritual resources there are in their traditions. Of course for us Christ is central. Hopefully they may see there are more of the needed resources in Christ. But we should not make conversion a condition of working with them or supporting them if they agree with our goals of human flourishing.
This will involve developing a public theology - an expression of how biblical resources and Christian faith engages with the challenges and issues facing a community - it may be a Christian approach to bringing emergency relief, to extending educational opportunities, to communication or to ensuring integrity in business and political life.
For all this theological educators cannot act alone. We just do not have enough skills and resources. There will need to be collaboration: collaboration between residential institutions and those with experience of training people who are already engaged in ministry; collaboration with other training programmes to enhance each other’s resources ( for example at OCRPL we have greatly benefitted from collaboration with Barnabas Fund and their links with churches in situations of persecution and with four universities in Africa to benefit from their expertise and academic standards in post-graduate work); collaboration with people and churches in fruitful ministry both with poor communities and the world of business and politics, not for their money but for their expertise in training people for ministry. I worked for some time for the BBC as a religious programmes producer and greatly benefitted from training placements to which I was sent at college and in my curacy.
So as we rethink transformational theological education we need to remember four of the pillars of transformational theology: a new
70
identity in Christ, through being born again into the kingdom of God, which is good news to poor people and which will fulfil the stewardship to which everyone is called in a new heaven and new earth, made possible by the death and resurrection of Jesus.
As we craft our curriculum to train our colleagues in this theological perspective we must remember that theology alone is not enough. We must point people to and immerse them in models and examples of where such ministry is taking place and enrol such ministries as collaborators in our work of theological education.
71
Rethinking Transformational Theology for the Public Square16 Canon Vinay Samuel
Introduction: This essay will attempt a rethinking of Christian Mission as Transformation, particularly its engagement in the public square that has spanned nearly four decades and something that I am connected with since its beginnings.
The concept of Mission as Transformation was adopted by socially committed evangelicals in the early 1980’s as it enabled them to see social engagement as integrating belief, development and action for social and political transformation. It was resisted for a while by evangelicals who had social concerns but could not see socio-political action as part of Christian mission engagement.
The spread of Evangelical Social Engagement as transformation of society gained steam as evangelicals from countries where poverty was a major problem recognised that Christian mission included social change and began using the language of transformation.
Evangelicals, particularly in the West, who were reluctant to engage directly in tackling systems that perpetuated poverty and prejudice (like racism & classism) did believe change was needed but believed that changing hearts and turning them to Christ was a priority and that along with prayer will being change. But the experience of believers who converted to Christianity from the historically excluded and oppressed “untouchables” and lowest casts of India showed that poverty and oppression persisted for not one generation but in many cases up to four generations. Social change as a natural outcome of conversion was not universally true. In fact, change for full civil rights of people, for inclusion and economic opportunity did not happen naturally and gradually. It had to be addressed, often struggled for and gained as in the case for civil rights of African Americans in the United States of America.
This transition of evangelicals from social action passivity to social engagement for change was led largely by evangelicals from the non-western world with increasing support from their brothers and sisters in the west. C.B. Samuel and I had the privilege of being part of the transition enabling Mission as
16 From Public Theology- Exploring Expressions of the Christian Faith edited by Bonnie Miriam Jacob. TRACI India 2020. Available on Kindle.
72
Transformation to become mainstream among evangelicals. We recognised Transformation had become mainstream when a leader of a global evangelism organisation based in the United States adopted the terminology and with it a wholistic understanding of the gospel mandate. He was Transformation’s severe critic in the 1980’s and 90’s.
In this essay I will examine some of the key theological themes of the understanding of Mission as Transformation, revisit their sources and influences and suggest how they may develop for the 21st century.
A. Uncovering and reviewing the ideas and influences that shaped the concept of Mission as Transformation among evangelicals. Evangelical development of Mission as Transformation has its roots in the challenge posed by Latin American liberation theologians as they drew their understanding of a Christian approach to poverty and oppression from the Bible itself in the 1970’s. Latin American Liberation theologians, many of them catholic priests and scholars drew from the refreshing theological changes that were crafted at the Second Vatican Council. Vatican II took the social mission of the church seriously. It gave impetus to a focus on human development. It also sought to identify the causes of under development of the “third world” as it was then called. The connection between the poverty of the third world and the wealth of the western world was also examined by the Church. Catholic theologians like Gutierrez, Segundo, Gesa joined with protestant theologians like Castro, Santa Ana, Alves and Bonino and began to reflect on Christian approaches to addressing poverty. Themes like praxis, periphery and centre, preferential option for the poor and liberation all began to tumble out of their reflection and writings. The first book that came out was “A Theology of Liberation” by Gustavo Gutierrez in 1971 in Spanish. I had the strange privilege of reading a review of it in English in 1972 while a student in the U.K. It’s themes were Christology and Ecclesiology. Evangelical scholars like Samuel Escobar, Rene Padilla, Orlando Costas began to respond to the Lain America liberation theologians. They saw that liberation theology was biblically rooted - Ernesto Cardinal’s “The Gospel in Solentiname” published from 1975 to 1977 showed how poor peasants read and understood the Gospel without the mediation of millennia of church tradition or scholarship. They had gospel centred discussions and analysed their situation and developed plans of action.
There is also a European background to the developments of liberation theology in Latin America. In the Post Second World War period Catholic Leaders and Scholars in Europe faced a devastated landscape. Their theology
73
of public engagement moved from the church building civil society as it had for many centuries to largely shaping the political sphere and political institutions for the ends of social transformation. Their thinking inspired some of their Latin American students who went on to develop liberation theology. Shaped by interaction with liberation theology Latin American evangelical scholars like Padilla and Escobar participated in the historic Lausanne Congress in 1974. Padilla’s plenary presentation on the biblical teaching of the world, a study of the word “cosmos” brought the themes of social Transformation to the heart of evangelical debate. It was providential that Lausanne adopted a resolution to affirm social engagement as an integral part of Christian mission.
B Gospel and the Poor
I wish to examine the theological themes that deal with poverty in Transformational theology. As Evangelicals developed their theologies of development Justice, empowerment and equality became the theological themes at the heart of addressing poverty.
1. Justice was recognised as a strong overarching theme due to its ubiquitous presence in the prophetic literature of the Old Testament, Images, narratives of justice beginning with the experiences of God’s people in Egypt, the Exodus event all flooded evangelical reflection and preaching to encourage evangelicals to adopt “seeking justice” and “struggle for justice” as a mission imperative.
Evangelicals accepted the analysis that the power of the powerful dictated, created and sustained social conditions of exclusion, marginalisation and oppression of poor peoples. They believed that the biblical message was that justice as the Rule of God and God’s Law’s for humanity must shape social and political institutions and life. Ensuring universal human rights in the laws and constitutions of countries, ensuring protection and implementation of rights became a key agenda for action.
Early in evangelical discussions a difference arose about the way biblical justice is to be understood. Some western conservative evangelicals saw justice as what is owed to people. Non-western evangelicals insisted that Justice is positive and is what God intends for humans who he has made in his image. In the first view, justice is tied to people’s behaviour. The poor were often seen as responsible for their own poverty. They needed opportunity to change and move
74
out of their poverty. The second view linked Justice to God’s love integrally linked to his concern for the poor and insisted that the Bible does not teach God assessing why poor are poor but bends to uplift them, release them and set them free. This is also linked with the biblical view that justice is addressing and redressing wrong done to the poor. It is about the personhood of the poor rather than their behaviour. It recognises that poor and the powerful fail morally but God’s concern for the poor does not anywhere in God’s word judge the poor harshly for their poverty. On the contrary the word of God doubles down on the actions of the rich that enable and perpetuate poverty.
Dignity and Equality are other themes that are linked with Justice. The Arc of Justice bends in Holy Scripture and it bends towards the poor. Biblical justice as it relates to the poor is not blind but privileges the poor. The integral relation of justice to love enables us to see justice not as an abstract universal, a principle that is applied to every context. When justice is used like that in social action it often becomes brittle. When integrated with love justice gets contextualised, liberating and empowering.
Transformation theology has not adequately related justice to the biblical understanding of Incarnation. We have tended to use incarnation as a mission strategy. It is that, but it is also much more. The biblical teaching of Incarnation must shape over understanding and practice of justice. Justice is not just Conceptual; it is primarily an Ontological category in the Bible. God’s justice is not separate from his being. In the incarnation of Christ we see justice, truth and love in the flesh. This enfleshed understanding of justice is a powerful basis for social engagement. The universality of Law & Rights can become a very abstract concept and difficult to apply contextually. The Bible relates the work of the Holy Spirit to Law. Law is reconstituted by the operation of the Holy Spirit. Transformation theology needs to draw out more substantially the integral relationship between the Spirit and law.
2. I now turn to the theme of Empowerment that Christians engaged in addressing poverty have employed to inform their theology and strategy.
75
Deepa Narayan defines empowerment as “Empowerment is the expansion of assets and capabilities of poor people to participate in, negotiate with, influence, control and hold accountable institutions that affect their lives.” (Measuring Empowerment: Cross Disciplinary Perspectives. OUP. Delhi 2006. P5).
Freedom and Capabilities are goals of empowerment against the forces of institutions and structures that keep people poor and perpetuate poverty. The intention of poverty reduction action is to provide opportunity to the poor and enable agency of the poor.
So themes like freedom, capabilities, participation, structures, institutions, opportunity and agency are at the heart of mainstream development strategies. They were also adopted by evangelicals to shape their development thinking and action. Transformation theology has reflected on these ideas relating them to biblical teaching.
There was always tension about whether empowerment was an end in itself – producing an empowered poor with capabilities and opportunities to address the causes of their poverty or is empowerment a means to the end enabling people to move out of poverty. Is empowerment intrinsic or instrumental ask different contributors to the study edited by D. Narayan. Another issue raised is whether empowerment is to be seen as a universal concept applied contextually or is it always context specific. Again as empowerment has to do with people, is it at heart empowerment of the individual or the collective?
The ideas that shaped the understanding of empowerment have not been adequately related to the biblical teaching of empowerment. Biblical language of Christ’s promise to empower his people was used to relate possibly secular concepts to a biblical understanding. In the New Testament empowerment is a promise to God’s people. It is integrally related to the gift of the Holy Spirit. The power of the Holy Spirit endows the believer with the capabilities of addressing the “powers of this age” that seek to frustrate God’s purposes. Biblical teaching of empowerment is first about the identity formation of the
76
believer. John 1:12 asserts that those who believe in Jesus and receive him are empowered to become God’s children. One can see how this identity formation can include concepts like freedom, capability and agency. But they are integral to a person’s relationship to Christ and relating then to the poor collectively is a difficult task. Secondly empowerment in the New Testament is about being empowered to fulfil God’s mission (Acts 1:8) . The focus here is external and about service in Christ’s mission. Biblically empowerment is about identity and mission, about formation and service.
We need to explore Incarnation of Christ as the model of empowerment. For the Son of God, the second person of the Trinity, it was necessary to empty himself of all divine power to become truly and fully human. As the “second Adam” the human Jesus is filled with God as it was God’s original intention for humans created in God’s image. Jesus is filled with that power as the true human and so he could promise his disciples they too will exhibit the same power as they participate in his humanity .The “first Adam” failed as he fell to the temptation to become divine in himself and was cast out from God’s presence. In the Resurrection of Christ we see the complete image of the empowered incarnate Lord that transcends time and history. The resurrected Christ does not shed his humanity but takes it to heaven where it will be at the very throne of God himself eternally. Incarnation and Resurrection are two biblical themes that must inform our view of empowerment as they model how power and human personhood are related.
When Korean theologians developed their version of the theology of the poor called “Minjung theology” in the 1970’s they worked tirelessly to empower the poor. The lived among poor and facilitated agency, freedom, awareness, analysis etc. However, a vast percentage of the Korean poor joined Pentecostal/Charismatic churches as they hungered for an empowerment that changed their identity from Minjung to Children of God who also experienced individually and collectively the presence of God in their lives through a powerful experience of the reception of the Holy Spirit. For the poor identity transformation was most important rather than legal empowerments through justice, and human rights. Experience of tens of thousands of Dalits coming to Christ in India in the past 20 years confirms that in
77
their conversion they see empowerment to an identity that lifts them from the pressed down status they experienced for many generations and is worth paying the price of conversion.
In the West conversion is from a fierce independence of the individual that defies and rejects God to a submission to God’s will, acceptance of one’s sinfulness, throwing oneself on God’s mercy, submitting one’s will to God’s will, experiencing forgiveness and acceptance by God and discovering freedom and love in that submission. For the poor, particularly in India, conversion is the pathway to dignity and significance in an Indian culture that had crushed their will and trampled on their identity. Their identity was not self-made with a strong will to resist oppressive forces. It was a crushed identity. Acceptance as members of God’s family produces true inner release and a sense of being blessed. The poor long for inner release- the healing of a crushed soul and an embrace that made them know they belonged to God and his family that healed and empowered them within. At the heart of their new identity are healing and belonging and that is their empowerment. Experience of poverty is not just economic deprivation and political marginalization. It is a daily experience of obnoxious behaviour that assaults one’s sense of self, the bigotry that cuts deep, the generalised prejudice, negative attitudes, the discrimination and stereotyping. Healed within and belonging to God’s family is the Identity they seek.
Transformation theology should not lose the importance of justice, rights and equality in the understanding of empowerment of the poor but must relate it clearly to the biblical teaching of identity empowerment.
3. The Kingdom of God is the overarching theological theme that has shaped Transformation theology from the beginning. The Kingdom of God as God’s rule entering human history became a powerful theme. The teaching of Jesus about the Kingdom of God did not limit its operation to the sphere of the spiritual. The ethics of the kingdom covered all of human life, individual, communal and institutional.
It is the teaching of the Kingdom of God that enabled the Gospel to be seen as wholistic and gospels impact as transformational. A great deal of scholarly work was done in the past two decades by scholars like Richard Bauckham and
78
N.T. Wright on the background to the gospels and the teaching of the Kingdom of God. New Testament studies have drawn on the Jewish world of Jesus’ time. It was world of Second Temple Judaism that looked forward to the fulfilment of history in the coming of the Messiah. The Kingdom of God coming in and with Christ then is about the fulfilment of history, not just the restoration of the People of God but the whole of Creation. So, the Kingdom of God is the right basis for Christian engagement for Transformation of society and creation itself. Along with fulfilment we find in Jesus’ teaching about the Kingdom of God the theme of universality. The kingdom was not just about restoration of Israel, it extends to all peoples.
The New Testament portrays two visions of what a Kingdom is like. We see this stark contrast in the encounter of the Roman Governor Pilate with Jesus himself. Rome stood for a kingdom based on raw human power. It is the power of those who can organize, resource and rule nations. Against that power Jesus speaks of the kingdom based on truth. But here truth is not just a different way of knowing and making meaning of the world. It is truth incarnated in a person - the word became flesh full of grace and truth. So, arrayed against a kingdom constructed by human power is the kingdom shaped by love, grace, sacrifice and truth. The rulers of the world are judged by the criteria of kingdom Jesus inaugurates and embodies. When Transformational mission activists draw on the kingdom of God to develop their strategies and outcomes for wholistic mission, they need to be aware of the contrast between the kingdoms of the world and the Kingdom of God. Kingdom initiatives and mission activities must reflect this tension and contrast.
Another area that needs further examination is the nature of a community that reflects the Kingdom of God. Transformational mission is about building communities of wholeness (Shalom) and justice. The teaching of Jesus stresses the rule of God. What is the nature of the community that the teaching of Jesus outlines? Does the teaching of the Kingdom of God privilege communities of the poor as is sometimes stressed in transformational theology? We need to imagine the community that exhibits the rule of God.
Further, along with the inbreaking of the Kingdom of God in human history, we have the incarnation of God himself in history, his death in history and his resurrection. Incarnation, crucifixion and resurrection all occurred in history. While using the Kingdom of God as the template for transformational mission
79
we must relate it integrally to the Incarnation, Crucifixion and Resurrection of Christ
C. Context and the search for rootedness
Transformational theology made the local central to its theological reflection and understanding. It did not reject the universal formulations of theology but rigorously tried to relate the often inherited and assumed universal theological formulations to the local and contextual. Transformation theology is always plural as expressed in local theologies of transformation.
The drive to privilege the local comes from social justice activists who seek rootedness by focussing on “the subjective, embodied and social determinative experience” (Tara Isabella Boutton, in Comment 2020 “Past Liberal Epistemology” ).
Rootedness means race, gender and other identity makers became central in the search for justice. The focus shifted to identity justice in many cases overshadowing economic and political justice.
This move to the psychological meant that for some at least self-actualisation was based on the freedom of the will to fashion their identity as they desired. Others found their rootedness in biology and biological determinism. So contextual means search for rootedness to identify the context you belong to and from which you derive your identity. The identity of the poor is rooted in the context of poverty. The identity of the marginalized is rooted in the context of marginalisation, other factors of understanding poverty and marginality become secondary and at best derivative.
Rootedness is not just about the social context but also our experience as embodied persons with particular backgrounds, culture, race and also biological endowments. We are addressed as embodied persons by others not just as belonging to a context as that can be reductionist. Our particularity as embodied persons prevents us being seen as an expression of a universal. This is particularly true of the poor. A poor person should not be seen as representing the universal category of the poor. It is this refusal by the poor to be just expressions of a context of oppression and poverty but privilege their lived experience that explains why their choices do not necessarily align with the concerns for justice for the context that activists focus on.
80