Clash of
Narratives
Long ago Huntington wrote the thesis with a title on Clash of
Civilizations, referring to the future conflicts based on the cultural
groupings rather than ideological or economical groups. The thesis was so
convincing that many interpret the conflicts and fault lines based on
Huntington’s ideas. However, recent conflicts were often within the cultural
groupings rather than between the clusters of cultural similar groups. This
raises many questions about the thesis itself whether Huntington got it right. Then
when one goes through the reviews of this thesis including of Tariq Ali,
Chomsky and Said, it is not convincing or persuasive enough to go back to
economic based or ideological based interpretation of conflicts or nation
states evolution. Though Edward Said’s argument based on ignorance seems
compelling (under the title of Clash or Ignorance), yet, articulated public
ignorance through media reports, research findings on public opinion and
perception of the other show clear evidence in this favour, yet, there are some
identifiable narratives and ideas that contribute to this ignorance that
contribute to conflicts in many contexts. Of course people’s ignorance in terms
of not knowing the other or being exposed to selective negative information
about the other is an important source of suspicion, confrontation and violent
conflicts, yet the articulated narratives by various vested groups provide a
platform for such ignorance that leads to conflicts. This necessitates an
argument in favour of clash of narratives as one of the main sources of
conflicts.
So I wish to make a case that today many conflicts can be
interpreted in terms of clash of narratives, narratives of fear, narratives of
suspicion, narratives of conflicts and narratives of war. Narratives are those
structured thought pattern within a few organised sentences that define the
identity of the self and the other. In the conflicts between Russia and Ukraine
we hear the narratives, narrative that Russia is worried about being surrounded
by NATO; narrative that Russian language was not given a second language status
in Ukraine; narrative that Russian majority areas wanted to be separate from
Ukraine and narrative that some nazi movements can be found in some parts of
Ukraine. There are also narratives in Ukraine, narrative of Russia being a big
nation is aggressive towards small new nation; narrative that Ukrainians would
benefit by joining EU that might automatically bring them into NATO; narrative
of getting rid of dominance of Russian speaking communities in Ukraine. Two
sides have these narratives emerged from some corners, yet emerged to be
dominant in influencing and becoming the public opinion and worldviews. While
politicians in the democratic process with a polarising mind can use these
narratives to their advantage in the election, the media are in competition
with each other at times in maximising the sensational news to their ratings as
much as possible. To some extent the involvement of Saudi Arabia in Yemen can
also be interpreted in a similar way of conflict of narratives of Shia and
Sunni and the aspiration to achieve power and control the other. Often such
narratives use selective evidences and news information about the other in a
negative light.
The “selective reductionism” can provide proofs to the public
to be convinced of the polarising narratives either way. The Selective
reductionism means media selects one event or incident as news story and then
generalize as if their story is representation of the whole other. For example,
the news media can present an attack by Russian separatists in one incident as
an attempt trying to take over Ukraine back to them. Sadly, this style of
public reporting or news has become a norm or practice in many countries,
particularly in local language news media. An interplay between the politicians
and the media in using such narratives for their advantage has not only
polarised communities but also has made the relations between majority and
minority, between linguistic or religious or caste groups strained and small
scale violence has become a reality in many part of the world.
Many narratives exist among communities and nations both in
public and private spaces. Among them, two of them are dominant in terms of
influencing the global discussions and contribute to confrontation at various
levels. One of them is the liberal
narratives of sex as freedom. Recently the Russian Patriarch (the leader of the
Russian Orthodox Church) referred to this as a Western drive on others,
particularly Gay pride movement in Ukraine as a threat to Christianity and to
culture as Russians and so such a movement must be put off even through a
conflict. He wrote to World Council of Churches in order to justify the
Russia’s war against Ukraine, though the Russian President himself referred
before the Patriarch. Many in East and among the religious South people think
that the Western liberal culture has moved away from traditional values, though
they too share these liberal values such as equity, freedom and fairness. Nevertheless,
the understanding of freedom, equity and fairness has moved from a reasoned
negotiations or reconstruction to an ideology driven movement. In this
ideologically driven movement, the persuasion of what is right has become
dominant and thus people use the narratives to justify whatever they tend to do
in terms of sex, treatment of others and politically corrected ideas. This has
brought down many other values such as family values, community values and even
international values and caused an anarchy in many parts of West. This has led
even political miscalculations such as narratives of Iraq War creating a global
disorder in which there is a deficiency of trust.
This is what the national and religious narratives are trying
to resist such popular liberal narratives. When one of the regional parties in
Bombay (now it is known as Mumbai in India) Shiv Shena showed this opposition
openly by throwing the valentines cards from the shops and burned them in
public. Since then they became the ruling party in this state. Some of the
counter narratives, such as Salafists in Islam (being trained in Saudi Arabia –
now they have become a global movement) wanted to resist the Western education
altogether and thus to fight the Western education, they have organised
themselves as armed groups such as Boko Haram in Nigeria and Cameroon in Africa. The idea is to resist
these liberal values that they see as a threat to family and community values,
as a challenge to Islam and thus for the Salafists or a Hindu nationalists, to
protect their religion, their community values they need to fight these
narratives at the core and thus defend the purity of their faith and values.
The second most popular narratives that affect us all is the
neo-liberal narrative. This has permeated our economy, society national
structures and global trade and controlled to many extent the whole business
and other relationship around the world. While many seem to be benefited from
this narrative in terms of liberalisation of economy and improvement of
services, the promises that are made, such as competition will improve the
quality and bring down prices. The taxes would be reduced. These promises
remained in words and not yet converted into realities. Therefore, we have high
taxing system while the private companies enjoy the control of the public and
private spaces.
The self-regulation is a good theory and many decisions to
correct them happened only in the courts. One of the narratives of neo-liberal
method is the survival of the fittest in which the hardworking and intelligence
would grow while those who do not work hard, risk or use their intelligence,
would lack behind. Such narratives enabled many to be greedy and cunning that
the economy has become a high risk factor in which many people’s lives and jobs
are affected at times by a few individuals and their decisions. While dignity of all human beings and fair
share of wealth to people are being believed by many religions and communities,
this economic concept has created a fear among many people. Such neo-liberal
narratives are combined with the previous liberal narratives. The majoritarian
communities and their leaders tended to blame the minority or the neighbours
for their problems and thus create narratives of conflicts or war. Even the
majoritarian leader in order to distract the majority tend to blame the
neighbours or majority for their failures in the neo-liberal economy and
mismanagement.
For me, the above evidence clearly points out the fact that
if we wish to understand the conflicts today and address them we need to move
away from the Clash of civilisation to the clash of narratives. In order to
address the conflicts one may have to see how counter narratives of peace and
justice can be shared (which are already existing among many cultures,
religions and languages), at wider levels. Only when we name the narratives of
conflicts or narratives of suspicion we can also work towards the narratives of
justice and peace among nations and communities. For creating such narratives,
we need reason and faith as two important tools to negotiate and find new ways
of living and relating to each other in an alternative global order.
Canon Revd
Dr Joshva Raja John
Former Dean
of Oxford Centre for Religion and Public Life
Honorary
Canon of Birmingham Cathedral, UK
Head of
International Bible Advocacy Centre.