Sunday, 29 July 2007

Models of Mission in the context of Religious Pluralism

Communication Models and Mission in the context of Religious Pluralism

Jesus engaged in his hearer’s search for meanings whereas today most of the missionary activities and models treat the audiences as mere receivers of the gospel.

Understanding Mission:
Mission in Christian context refers to propagation of the gospel, expansion of the reign of God, conversion of the non-Christians and the founding of new churches (Muller 1987 quoted by Borsch 1997:1). This is in line with one of the Jesus’ commands to his disciples in the gospels (Matthew 28:18-20) even though conversion from one religion to the other is not explicit in the text. Many of the missionary organisation and the churches are involved in carrying out the mission of the church rather than God’s mission. The mission of the church includes expansion of the church, proselytism and propagation of the gospel whereas the purpose of God’s mission is to enable human beings to establish relationship with God and with other fellow beings. As Christians we believe that God continues to interact with human beings through Jesus Christ in order to bring them closer to him and to others. I will also highlight the difference between mission of the church and God’s mission in and through Jesus Christ. I will try to study and analyse the practice of mission using three models of communication – Transmission model, Circular model and Ritual model.

1. Transmission Model of Mission
In this model the missionary takes the gospel to the non-Christian audience. The message is transmitted from the church through the missionary to the audience. In this sense the mission involves sender, receiver, message and medium. Usually the transmission model dominates many of the churches’ mission practices in India Today. Many of our church and para-church organisations send their missionaries from South to North India (e.g. FMPB/IMS/NMS) and convert the non-Christian communities to Christianity. Some of their missionaries try to prove that they are more powerful than the local medicine practitioner or black magicians. The churches assume that they possess the gospel message which they send through the missionaries to others. Once the non-Christians accept the gospel and become Christians then they too are supposed possess the gospel.
The gospel message is also communicated through south Indian cultural and doctrinal coatings. In most cases the converts are mostly from tribal and marginalised background. The missionaries in their approaches do not give importance to the receivers’ culture, beliefs and methods of communication. Rather the converts are alienated from their own culture and community. Such a model of mission is very close to the colonial model where the missionaries promoted their respective gospels and cultures. In this transmission model of mission the audiences and their contexts are not taken seriously. The sender (missionaries/sponsoring organisations), message (gospel/ doctrines) and the channel (flannel graph/filmstrips) were given importance in order to reach out the un-reached masses and to convert them to Christianity.
An implicit claim is made in this transmission model that the Gospel message is universal and is the truth, the way and the life for all human beings on earth. Having received this message from God through Jesus the churches are supposed to possess it and transfer it faithfully to all non-Christians. There is a claim that the churches and missionaries possess the gospel which must be proclaimed to others. Most of our missionary organisations follow the transmission model in which the role of the audience and their context are not given adequate importance in doing mission. By following this model some have failed to recognise the positive contribution of other religious communities to the mission. Some of them become apologetic and defenders of faith in their mission.
One of the main purposes of the transmission model is to proselytise non-Christians. It is assumed that the missionary possesses the gospel which is universally valid and so the audience has to accept it and thus give up their religion for Christianity. This has been severely criticised by many church organisations. The World Conference on Mission and Evangelism, held in Salvador, Bahia, 1996, declares: "many expressions of mission lead to unethical forms of coercion and proselytism which neither recognize the integrity of the local churches nor are sensitive to local cultures"[1996]. The WCC's Central Committee meeting 1997 approved a document called "Towards Common Witness" where proselytism is considered a "scandal and counterwitness". The document calls upon "a clearer practice of responsible relationship in mission, a sharper commitment to witness in unity and renunciation of all forms of proselytism " [WCC 1997:204]. There is a wider condemnation of any practice of proselytism by the churches in the name of mission and evangelism.
Such a model of mission has, as J. Vekuyl [1978] suggests, "four impure motives” [Borch 1997:5] which are: 1. The imperialistic motive. The meaning of mission as "spreading the Christian faith among people" is closely associated with the colonial expansion of the Western world. 2.The cultural motive. Speaking at the San Antonio Conference, Lesslie Newbigin made reference to his own cultural background in these terms: "As I look back on my own life as a missionary in India, I realize now in a way that I never did at that time that I was not only carrying the gospel but that I was also a carrier of this so-called modern world-view which I now see to be breaking down because it is false… But that judgment I was making was shaped more by my training as an Englishman, a product of an English school and university education, than the judgment that arises from living in the world of the Bible." [1958] 3. The romantic motive. The desire to go far away, to live in exotic countries, to meet exotic people, sometimes was the incentive offered for recruiting new missionaries. 4. The motive of ecclesiastical colonialism. Throughout its history Western Protestantism was fractured into a great variety of denominations. Denominations were created on a voluntary basis. Some of these critical remarks are applicable not only to the international missionary organisations but also to many Indian mission and church organisations.

2. Circular Model of Mission
The primary task of mission is to communicate the gospel to all. While doing mission many have attempted to take audience seriously. In order to evangelise the people missionaries have identified and used their cultural codes. The missionary had to recognise the public code of the audiences in order to communicate the gospel and encode the message within the framework of signs and codes that are shared. The audiences may differ in decoding the gospel. The communicator needs to recognise and decode the audiences’ common code before he/she encodes the gospel message to be communicated [Hall 1980; Durham and Kellner 2001:166]. In order to encode into a public message, the audiences’ shared codes need to be recognised and decoded. Mission will be effective if this process is taken seriously.
DeNobili is one of the best examples for this encoding model. He worked with the presupposition that the audiences’ cultural and religious codes cannot be totally neglected. For him missionary should be become part of the audiences’ society by accepting their cultural and religious practices and communicate effectively using such codes [Pillai 1984:284]. He encoded some of the Hindu Braminical priestly codes in order to communicate the gospel to the Hindu communities. There were also other attempts to encode some of the audiences’ accepted codes such as Ashram model. Thangasamy [1948:209] noted that evangelisation through the Ashram was successful among the Hindus in India. The atmosphere in Ashram is such that people of other faiths feels at home when they visit the place. Ashram is way to encode the gospel message and communicate to the non-Christian Indian audience.
This model is circular in which the audience’s code is given importance. But the problem with this model of mission is that the audiences’ role is limited only to ‘receiving’ and also to ‘sharing’ codes. The assumption behind this model is that the communicator possesses the content which he/she would encode through the shared code that is used by the audience. This model points to a wider model which is ritual model in which sharing and participating is emphasised.

Ritual model of Mission
Mission is an ongoing process in every religion through which people are converted from one state of thinking to another state of thinking. It is part of human beings ritual process in which everyone is involved in search for new meanings of their faith and culture that would be relevant and effective to their ever-changing contexts. In this model mission would mean participating in ongoing search for meanings of faith. We engage along with God in search for new meaning of life and faith. In such a context mission needs to be defined in terms of sharing, participating, and interacting with the people of God in their search for meanings that would bring them closer to God[1]. This recognises the fact that even before the gospel is communicated the people are engaged in search for meanings through their culture and religious that would bring them to God. In such a context mission means to engage in their ongoing search for meanings that would bring them closer to God. Such a model is not a new one because there are examples New Testament that Jesus engaged in people’s search for meanings that would bring them closer to God.
The political and economic context, culture and religion provide a framework for our mission. By engaging in the audiences’ search for meanings of faith and life, we take part in God’s mission. This means the mission begin from the people where they are and accept people as they are. Our mission begins when we start listening and learning from the people. The conversion first has to happen in the missionary rather than among the audience. Without which conversion becomes a contest between different religions and so a destructive force in a multi-faith context. The conversion in the missionary is that he/she has to recognise, learn and engage in their search for meanings and then present gospel meanings among the available meanings. As I highlighted already Jesus also engaged in his hearers’ search for meanings. Christian mission means engaging, participating and interacting with the ongoing search for meanings that would bring people closer to God.
The first step is for the church to engage with others. In this sense it is to break the usual sense of “We” and to try to engage with the “other”. Dietrich Bonhoeffer [1971:382 – taken from Borsch 1997:375] wrote: “The church is the church only when it exists for others… The church must share in the secular problems of ordinary human life, not dominating, but helping and serving”. On the one hand the church is called to communicate the gospel narrative and on the other she should become the part of the gospel narrative that would bring people to God. In this sense the content and the being cannot be separated. In this sense the church becomes the medium and message of the gospel for herself and for others [McLuhan] . The church becomes the gospel when she participates in the others’ search for meanings of life and of faith. Without “becoming” and “being” the gospel, any exclusive claim for the gospel narrative would look like another fundamentalist’s war narrative competing for superiority of religion. Because the church is not confident in becoming the gospel she tends to separate her praxis away from the content.
The second step in mission is to engage with people in search for meanings of justice, peace, reconciliation, liberation, community-building, love, dialogue and common-witnessing [Borsch 1997:368f]. It becomes a mandate for the churches’ mission that they participate with others in their search for meanings of peace and so on. By engaging in others’ struggles the church not only proclaims the gospel but also becomes the gospel. In this engagement the church becomes a co-learner and a listener as well as a witness to the gospel. John Stott [1975:23] pointed out saying: “I now see more clearly that not only the consequences of the commission but the actual commission itself must be understood to include social as well as evangelistic responsibility, unless we are to be guilty of distorting the words of Jesus. Many missionary organisations and NGOs are already engaged in different development and social awareness activities. Our social responsibility and services should not be isolated from our witnessing and from our engagement in others’ search for meanings. Without bringing the people into closer relation with God and with other fellow beings either in their own way or through the gospel, the social service becomes one-sided view of the mission.




Borsch, David J. Transforming Mission: Paradigm Shifts in Theology of Mission. New York: Orbis Books, 1997.
Towards Common Witness, Appendix VI, Minutes of the Forty-eighth Meeting, Central Committee, WCC, Geneva, 1997, pp. 198-211.
Conference Message and Acts of Commitment, Conference on World Mission and Evangelism, Salvador, Bahia, Brazil, 1996.
Newbegin, Lesslie. One Body, One Gospel, One World. London: International Missionary Council, 1958.
Hall, Stuart. Et.al. ‘Encoding/Decoding’, Culture, Media and Language. London: Hutchinson, 1980.
Durham, M G. and Kellner, D M. Media and Cultural Studies: KeyWorks. Massachusetts: Blackwell.2001.
Pillai, M ‘Communication of the Bible Message in India: To the Poorly Educated Masses’, Indian Theological Studies, 21, 1984, 3-4, 269-295.
Thangasamy, P A. ‘The Evangelistic Need and Opportunity’,The South India Churchman, September 1948, 209-212.
Bonhoeffer, Dietrich, Letters and Papers from Prison. The Enlarged Edition, London: SCM, 1971.
Stott, J R W. Christian Mission in the Modern World. London: Falcon, 1975.
Huntington, Samuel P.1996, The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of the World Orders. Delhi: Viking.
Said, Edward. The Clash of Ignorance, Media Monitors Network, October, 11, 2001, http://www.mediamonitors.net/edward40.html.
Said, Edward. 1997, Covering Islam: How the Media and the Experts determine how we
see the Rest of the World. Amazon.
Tariq, Ali, 2001, The Clash of Fundamentalisms: Crusades, Jihads and Modernity.
London: Verso, 2002.
[1] From a Ritual Perspective communication is defined in terms of ‘sharing’, ‘participating’, ‘interacting’ and ‘exchanging’ [Carey:1989,18]. Through communication we participate in the process of constructing, sharing and exchanging ‘meanings’. These meanings reinforce and shape our values, attitude and worldviews.

No comments: