Tuesday, 4 October 2022

Missio En Deo -Reconstructing Holistic Mission with an alternative vision of Misso En Deo . Joshva Raja

 

 

Reconstructing Holistic Mission with an alternative vision of Misso En Deo

 

 

Recently I came across the ideas that there is a problem with the understanding of mission in which we are called to participate. God is emphatically seen as the other with whom humans are invited to participate. This idea of God as the other who cares loves serves and guides humanity according to God’s will is a dominant one among many Christians. This act of God demands every disciple of Jesus Christ to act accordingly. But the invited participation is seen as an option to the disciples of Jesus Christ which they can refuse or reject or obey. In terms of caring, serving and loving others, particularly those in margins, the options are often seen as part of choices for the disciples of Jesus. In such options and choices, today there is also an argument from individualism. Today more than ever before both reasoned human and self-centered human being part of considerable majority secular humans, raise questions about care that includes caring for the elderly, disabled or margins. Because God is seen as the other and doing the mission as an outsider, we have choices to participate or to reject.

 

Sadly this leads to many questions including why should one waste one’s own life caring, loving and serving others? Why not one should live one’s own life fully letting others go if they cannot survive by themselves? If there is an ability to find an autistic foetus at early months, why not get aborted and get a good baby which would satisfy and fulfill one’s life with reasonable joy. With such arguments, there has been euthanasia for elderly in Europe – being persuaded by themselves to volunteer or being indirectly pressurised to commit it by others, though it looks a volunteer act at the end and also abortion for a foetus with a disability. In such contexts I wish to make a case arguing if we see our mission as part of God’s mission and if we can participate within the essence of triune God, then such caring, loving and serving become an inevitable and essential part of our mission, our completeness of life and our own salvation within Godhood. This would also reveal interdependency, interactivity, inter-relationality, and interconnectivity as the means of discovering our own purpose and God’s will for us in this world and thus our own salvation depends on our caring of others and thus our life is complete within Godhood by giving up our lives in order to care others. This is why I am trying to come up with the concept of Missio En Deo – Mission in Triune Godhood.

 

What is Missio En Deo and why?

In simple terms, this can refer to the mission in Godhood. It also includes not only we are called to participate in the mission of God, but also inviting God to participate in the searching and solidarity mission of human beings. Out of generosity God invites us to participate in his triune community’s discussing in shaping, developing and sharing the purpose and meanings for human world and in discovering the meanings of life, truth and being together with God.  In this sense it is participating mission within the triune Godhood in shaping, sharing and discovering the meanings together. This comes out of the generosity of God not necessarily natural. 

 

This idea is not an Advaitic (non-dualist Indian Philosophy) as when people reach realization they become one with the ultimate being and our essence of being, comes out of this ultimate being. This idea of merging into one is not similar to missio en deo. This is also not highlighting the presence of God in everything or everything can be seen as gods as some pantheistic people would look at. While the presence of God is there everywhere, human beings are invited and welcomed by God himself in order that human beings would be able to participate in the decisions and engagement of God.

 

This idea evolves from three other ideas within the New Testament narratives. First from the use of “In Christ” by Paul in his letters such an idea is being developed. Second the use of the metaphor of the Body of Christ which Paul describes for unity and status of leaders with different roles in the church. The Third is the idea of the Trinity as a community and as space. There may be a fourth idea emerging from the Gospel of John the metaphors of wine and branches leading Jesus to say we in them and they in us – making the interconnectedness and interdependence of human and God in doing mission together.

 

Being in Christ (Missio En Christo)

It is important to recognise the fact that Paul uses, ‘En Christo’ in more than one sense or with diverse meanings relating to textual or wider contexts[1]. We can sympathize with Schweitzer’s convergence of the phrases, ‘Fellowship with Christ’; Belonging to Christ with the phrase, ‘in Christ’ and thus refers to the mystical participation in Christ and his body[2]. Ridderbos tries to define Paul’s in Christ as an abiding reality which is determinative for the whole of the Christian life[3]. Dunn concluded it as a consciousness of Christ[4].

 

I wish to highlight some references where Paul highlights the importance of being in Christ. For Paul being in Christ means as Disciples of Christ and members of the church or the body of Christ, we are in Christ, we live in Christ, we act in Christ, we do mission in Christ and we do everything in Christ. In the letter to Colossians 1:16f he writes in him (in Christ) all things hold together (Ephesians 1:9f). Paul refers to individuals or group of people or saints being in Christ.  In Philippians 1:1 the saints in Christ; those who are in Christ Jesus (Romans 8:1) and a man in Christ (2 Corinthians 12:2)[5]. Paul also urges Thessalonians to do in the Lord Jesus more and more (1 Thessalonians 4:1). He calls them to rejoice in the Lord (Phil 3:1); the peace of God will guard your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus; to present everyone in Christ (Col 1:28).

 

Paul identifies the churches of Judea as being in Christ. Possibly being a Christian or member of the early Church, it is possible to be identified as being in Christ. It is possible to argue with specific and selective examples that being in Christ means sharing the mind of Christ, acting as if one is Christ, living as if one is the living body of Christ, witnessing as if one is in Christ. It also opens up a question that the resurrected Christ is no more a dead person but a living in and through Eucharist. Christians are invited to become part of this being in Christ which refers to living in Christ, sharing and doing mission in Christ. This does not make everyone Christ but every Christian has a role in completing what is known as “Christ”. Christ is something of an open and welcoming creative presence of God through Jesus in which Christians are called to be part of, participate in the mission with the mind of Christ, as if they are part of the body of Christ and as if they are part of Christ.

 

This takes us to the next metaphor which is the Body of Christ. A few ideas are emerging from the phrase being in Christ, in Christ there is no male and no female (Galatians 3:28 There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free, nor is there male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus.). There are ideas of solidarity, merging into the perfection of Christ as one in Christ, becoming like Christ, acting and living as if we are Christ as if we share the features of Christ as if we live like Christ.  In 1 Corinthians 3:17, Paul writes whoever is united with the Lord is one with him in spirit. Romans 12:5 summarises that in Christ we, though many, form one body, and each member belongs to all the others. This is what I wish to highlight in my article as well. Our salvation is interdependent and interlinked with one another in Christ rather than our own activities as individuals or as separate communities (denominations) or even as faith communities or as nations. There is an idea of union with Christ, union with believers and also implicitly union with humanity in terms of interdependence, interactivity, interlinks in terms of becoming one in Christ. This is something hard to imagine but a challenge to widen our vision to imagine and translate it into the reality of being, living and doing mission in Christ in today’s world as if we are Christ. This inevitable communion demands us to realize and care for each other as a mandate and as inevitable realization and act of our own salvation rather than as an invited option of separate organisms or individuals to achieve their own salvation with their own action and life.

 

Body of Christ

Paul’s second metaphor is the Body of Christ. He uses it to describe the church in terms of a community of Christians, Fellowship in terms of space and unity in terms of relationship. This reveals interconnectedness, interrelatedness and interdependence of one with the other in the body of Christ. Though it is a metaphor, it does create an idea of real space, real relations, real structures, real institutions and real communities. It is real because Christians come together as members, as participants and as part of the whole of a body that gives them recognition, role and life as Christian[6]. In 1 Corinthians 12: 27, Paul writes, ‘Now you are the body of Christ and each one of you is a part of it’. This is very clear in the whole of this chapter how each part of the body needs to recognise its own role and also others within the body of Christ. How to rejoice together when one part is honoured and the clear emphasis is: 12:20 as it is, there are many parts but one body. Such unity in the body of Christ clearly highlights that it is not uniformity or sameness that one tends to achieve rather building connectedness, relationship, participation, recognition, the solidarity of one another within the body of Christ while differences are kept, celebrated and appreciated. In such a non-monolithic body of Christ, different gifts are brought in and shared. 

 

In Ephesians 4:16 Paul writes from him the whole body, joined and held together by every supporting ligament, grows and builds itself up in love, as each part does it work. Here the body of Christ not only is dynamic, alive and active but also grows together with each part contributing to its growth[7]. As in Colossians 2:19 the church or fellowship cannot lose connection with the head which is Christ and without him, it cannot grow. In Colossians 1:17-18 it is clear that we are held together by Christ as the body of Christ. We Christians have a role within this body of Christ to unite ourselves together, appreciate one another and grow together by doing the mission with the head (Christ) as parts of the body of Christ. This metaphor affirms the interconnectedness, interrelatedness and interdependence of one another being part of the whole body of Christ. Christians do the mission as part of the body of Christ together in unity.

 

 

 

 

Trinity as community (Missio Trinitatis)

Moltmann claimed that the Trinitarian fellowship describes divine community and prescribes the nature of true human community. For him “true human fellowship is to correspond to triune God and be his image on earth.   The true human fellowship will participate in the inner life of triune God”[8]. I argue that Trinity is not merely an ideal community projected from within the human mind rather it is an open uniting and growing community with shared common rejoiced spaces; celebrated differences; the mystery of holding together even contradictions along with openness, welcoming and inviting spirit. It means that such a trinity is an open-ended processing community that grows taking the human participation within.  The unity is much emphasised on the basis of the moral union rather than in substance which is a weakness in Moltmann’s argument[9]. Yet St Augustine himself wrote, “If you see love, you see Trinity”[10]. For St Augustine, the imago Trinitatis means: “the lover, the beloved and the love which unites them” (VII,10,14). Martin Buber’s dialogical interpretation of Trinity with the idea of I exists only in relation to Thou were not taken seriously by those theologians who looked at individual based experiences (Barth and Rahner). Interestingly an internal unity of the Trinity being highlighted while such unity is often seen as a closed unity without realizing the fact that human Jesus brought his own contribution into this unity and thus became the first of all beings to be actively involved in this triune God. It is also interesting to note that though Moltmann and others looked at Trinity and the relations within, not many have looked at the way human participation in this community of Trinity, rather they looked at how one modelled the other or how one can be interpreted in terms of the other[11].

 

Interesting to refer to Habets’ quote, “knowledge is fundamentally relational, not merely cognitive; it is a personal knowing, that comes only by personal participation”[12].  T F Torrance asserts that knowledge of persons is only possible in reciprocal relations and that no one knows that Father except the Son and that perfect and complete knowledge of the other is only shared by them[13]. He goes by saying, We are given access to the closed circle of divine knowing between the Father and the Son only through cognitive union with Christ, that is only through the interrelation of knowing and being between us and the incarnate Son[14]. It is only through vertical participation in Christ that the church is horizontally a communion of love, a fellowship of reconciliation, a community of the redeemed. …. But it is only as we share with all saints in their relation to Christ that we participate deeply in the love and knowledge of God. Participation is conjoint participation, a participation-in-communion, but the communion is above all a communion-in- participation in Christ[15]. Torrance rejects the substantialilst approach for a relational trinity[16]. This is resonated with Veli-Matti Karkkainen’s comment that the move to relationality is also in keeping with the dynamic understanding of reality and the human being[17]. Such relational trinity will not be confined within the Godhead but freely and lovingly moves outward toward others whom God creates for fellowship with himself so that they may share with him the very communion of love which is his own divine Life and Being. In this understanding of relational Trinity, there is much more openness for participation within the Triune heart of God[18].

 

 

 

 

 

 

They in us and we in them

The Fourth Gospel emphasises the intimate union with God especially as mediated by Jesus the divine Logos (John 17:5). God is transcendent, the spirit, belonging to the mysterious heavenly sphere which is beyond human control (John 4:24)[19] and “yet God works in Jesus as Logos, directs his life and speaks divine words through Jesus (John14:10; 12:49f) so that the gap between the divine and humanity can be bridged”[20]. Being in God can be interpreted in multiple ways. It can mean dependence on God, conformity with his will, an ecstatic possession by the divine or a quasi-pantheistic absorption into the divine being[21]. This may not be the fourth evangelist would be thinking. Using different metaphors such as vine and branches (John15:1-17) the writer emphasises network of relationships inherent in communion with God. Through faith in Christ, we enter into a personal community of life with an eternal God. This divine indwelling is of such a nature that even a sacramental communion does not submerge the personality of the other[22]. The communion of Jesus with his disciples is founded on Jesus’ own communion with the Father and not in terms of distinct vertical (union with God) and horizontal (union with one another) categories[23]. Communion is to have fellowship (koinonia) with the Father and the Son, to share in their life[24]. It is manifested in the fellowship of love. In John 14:20, the idea of immanence[25] is well expressed which is an indwelling that extends beyond a communion of action.

 

We have seen the idea of how human involvement within the Triune God was explained in terms of different metaphors within the New Testament. Now we will raise the question: how the idea of the mission had evolved since 1910 and how the idea of Mission of God (missio Dei) evolved within the ecumenical circle. We will then ask the question: how the idea of God’s mission and our participation in God’s mission can lead to new challenges to the emerging contexts and also identify how these ideas of missio dei contribute to problems and thus there is a need for missio en Deo emerges as an alternative possibility. At first, we see how missio Dei has evolved through the missionary conferences across the world.  International Missionary Conferences are held by the mission agencies and churches around the world in different parts of the world.

 

From Missio Ekklesia to Missio Dei

 

There is an evolution in the understanding of Mission among the Christian Missiologists and Missionaries since the time of modern missionary movement. Let me begin with Edinburgh 1910 when ‘evangelising the non-Christians’ was seen as the main task of Christian mission. The theme "the evangelization of the world in this generation", was the main agenda of the conference[26]. It is clear that this was the only agenda even before Edinburgh 2010 for the missionary movement and also for many churches in terms of understanding Christian mission. The conference generally reflected a traditional approach to Christian mission, confining it to the proclamation of the "gospel to the heathens" with the spread of Western civilization. The missionaries and mission leaders were not much bothered with the relationship with other religions rather their question was: how to win non-Christians to Christ.

 

At the Jerusalem conference 1928, two major questions on mission emerged to which no real consensus was found: the relation between the Christian message and other religions, and the theological interpretation of Christian social and political involvement[27]. The discussion at Jerusalem centred around the relationship of such councils or missions to the ‘home’ church on the one hand and to the indigenous (younger) churches on the other. The dealings of the missionary societies with the indigenous churches were through these missions or councils. At Jerusalem, the younger churches desired a direct link between them and the societies and the churches they represented. They desired a church to church relationship.

 

The third mission conference (the second so-called "enlarged meeting" of the IMC) took place in 1938 in Tambaram, near Madras, India[28]. In a world context of fascist-type regimes (Germany, Italy, Portugal, Spain, Japan), the discussions focused on the importance and centrality of the church (in particular the local church) in the mission. Representatives from the so-called "younger" churches were in the majority in Tambaram. It is the Church and the Church alone (Missio Ekklesia) which can carry the responsibility of transmitting the Gospel from one generation to another, of preserving its purity and of proclaiming it to all creatures. It is the Church and Church alone which can witness to the reality that man belongs to God in Christ with a higher right than that of any earthly institution which may claim his supreme allegiance. It is within the Church and the Church alone that the fellowship of God’s people receives together with the gifts He offers to His children in Word and Sacrament.

 

The 1947 IMC conference in Whitby, Canada, was a small one. It reflected on the fundamental changes in what was considered a "revolutionary" world after the shock of the Second World War. There was a need to rebuild not only countries but also relations between people who had been in conflict. Whitby became famous for its slogan, "partnership in obedience". The term "partnership" had been used earlier, but it received particular emphasis at Whitby. Delegates abandoned the use of the language of "Christian" and "non-Christian" countries, opening the way to new paths in mission theology.  Christian mission agencies highlighted the importance of mission as evangelization of the world but only through the church and her mission agencies. The whole mission was strategically planned and funded. This is why the churches expanded their own versions of churches around the world by establishing denominations and thus dividing people more into different versions of Christianity. 

 

The idea of missio ekklesia was clear in the minds of early missionaries who promoted their own denominationalism rather than the Christian gospel in general. Even they did not bother converting other Christians into their fold and thus became very competitive in getting the numbers to their churches. They did not realize that even the New Testament had four gospels and the early Christians fought to avoid making them into one Gospel story. Only when they realized that coexistence and possibly a unity would make the gospel relevant to their contexts of mission. So in 1910, the missionaries tried to come together to discuss how to coexists in doing mission even without thinking how to coexist with other denomination in their own countries from where they were sent.

 

The next enlarged meeting of the IMC was in Willingen, Germany, in 1952. Under the threat of events in China to the traditional mission enterprise, delegates rediscovered that mission depends first and foremost on God’s own activity. Mission is the purpose and action of the triune God. Willingen 1952 is rightly considered to have had the most lasting influence on ecumenical mission theology. Indeed, the idea of missio Dei, that was taken up in the follow-up of Willingen, proved to be most creative. The strong emphasis on the centrality of the church in the mission (important since Tambaram) was replaced by an enlarged perspective that allowed an interpretation of world events as determining factors for the mission.

 

One of the missiologists Hoekendijk began to talk about the Mission of God rather than Mission of the Church.  The Missionary movement of which we are a part has its source in the Triune God Himself. Out of the depths of His love for us, the Father has sent forth His own beloved Son to reconcile all things to Himself. That we and all men might, through the Spirit, be made one in Him with the Father in that perfect love which is the very nature of God. We who have been chosen in Christ, reconciled to God through Him, made members of His Body, sharers in His Spirit, and heirs through hope of His Kingdom, are by these very facts committed to full participation in His redeeming mission.

 

To say that ‘the Church is the starting point and the goal of Mission’ is after all only making a phenomenological statement. It may well be that we are so wrapped up in our church-centrism that we hardly realize any longer how much our ideas are open to controversy. Would it not be a good thing to start all over again in trying to understand what it really means when we repeat, again and again, our favorite missionary text, ‘the Gospel of the Kingdom will be proclaimed throughout the Oikoumene - and attempts to re-think our ecclesiology within this framework of the kingdom -gospel-Apostolate-world?

 

There was also an understanding that the Christian mission can be done only by the churches – missio ekklessia against which mission of God (missio Dei) concept was developed in Willingen. Mission is often understood in terms of movement or transmission from God to human beings. This is why the church was called to disseminate the Gospel to all following the Great Commandment of Jesus (Mathew 28:18). It was reiterated by the International Missionary Council (IMC – part of the World Council of Churches) held at Thambaram in 1938. Having recognized the problems with the church centred mission, the IMC introduced the term Missio Dewe (Mission of God) replacing the Church centred Mission in 1952 at Willingen.  Karl Hartenstein who coined this term spoke of mission as “participation in the sending of the Son, in the Missio Dei, with an inclusive aim of establishing the lordship of Christ over the whole redeemed creation”[29].  For Karl Hartenstein, the mission is not simply a conversion from one religion to another, nor obedience to the word of God nor an obligation to go to the church. It is taking part in the in the sending of the Son, the Missio Dei, with the holistic aim of establishing Christ's rule over all redeemed creation.

 

 

Misso Dei and Missio Humanitatis!

 

Then theologians and missiologists came up with the idea of missio Dei which means the mission is not ours but God’s and thus we participate in the mission of God. Such concepts led to many other concepts and critical remarks. Some came up with the idea of missio Trinitatis, which means participating in the mission of triune God. Some were stuck to missio Christ – participating in the mission of Christ. So missio Dei with cosmos and God at the centre on the one hand and Christ as the centre on the other missionaries, missiologists and theologians engaged in the ongoing discussions in this concept.

 

In 1958, the IMC met in Achimota near Accra, Ghana, and debated a proposal to unite with the World Council of Churches, with which it shared several programmes and entertained intensive relations. The proposal was accepted by a great majority, while certain theologically more conservative mission councils refused to integrate mission and church. They wanted to preserve missionary freedom, and not become dependent on ecclesiastical authorities and agendas.

 

In 1961, the "integration" of church and mission - in practice of the IMC with the WCC - became effective at the assemblies of New Delhi. The mission councils affiliated to the IMC became affiliated to the Commission on World Mission and Evangelism of the WCC (CWME, later called Conference). The Division on World Mission and Evangelism (DWME, later, Commission) took over the programmatic work and responsibility of the IMC, which ceased to exist. From then on, the world mission conferences could really be called "ecumenical" because of the much larger denominational participation, including Orthodox churches and, soon after Vatican II, also Roman Catholic observers.       

 

In Geneva 1966, WCC CWME: As Christians, we are committed to working for the transformation of society. In the past, we have usually done this through quiet efforts at social renewal, working in and through established institutions according to their rules. Today, a significant number of those who are dedicated to the service of Christ and their neighbour assume a more radical or revolutionary position. They do not deny the value of tradition or social order, but they are searching for a new strategy by which to bring about basic changes in society without too much delay.

 

In WCC Bangkok 1972, the following statement was made, “To the world, he comes as the Lord of the universe, with deep compassion for the poor and the hungry, to liberate the powerless and the oppressed. To the powerful and the oppressors he comes in judgment and mercy. Without the liberation of Churches and Christians from their complicity with structural injustice and violence, there can be no liberating Church for mankind. We seek the Church which initiates actions for liberation and supports the work of other liberating groups without calculating self-interest”. The WCC delegates began to highlight the issues of justice as part of Christian Mission.

 

Melbourne 1980: The next CWME took place in Melbourne, Australia, in 1980. Reflecting on the theme "Your kingdom come", the conference insisted on the particular role of the poor and churches of the poor in God’s mission. Influenced by the Latin American liberation theologies, the delegates highlighted the radical aspects of the kingdom message, and the serious challenge it threw to traditional missiology and mission programmes.

 

In this context, Kasemann wrote, “Jesus will abolish every kind of domination, authority, and power and He is destined to reign until God has put all enemies under His feet. For us, the Kingdom of God is not primarily theory but praxis. Nor is it praxis concerned mainly with changed conditions, new possibilities, and goals. From the New Testament, the Christian standpoint, the kingdom of God denotes that praxis in which Jesus of Nazareth is our Lord and Saviour of the world". While the ecumenical understanding of mission is widened with WCC’s concept of “Justice, Peace, and Integrity of Creation” (commonly known as JPIC), the evangelical groups have struggled to include some of the contextual issues into their agenda.

 

The World Council of Churches’ statement from 1980 to 2000 have introduced as many as eight terms in relation to Christian mission – which are: liberative, prophetic, dialogic, participatory, development-oriented, proclamation, building communities and nourishes culture. Such concepts are developed and reflected in Catholic documents (the 1971 Synod of Bishops, Evangeliwe Nuntiandwe in 1975, and Redemptoris Missio of 1990) [Bevans].[30] In 1984, Secretariat statement highlighted the following elements of Christian mission: (1) presence and witness, (2) development and liberation, (3) liturgical life, prayer and contemplation, (4) interreligious dialogue, and (5) proclamation and catechesis[31].  Andrew Kirk added ecological concerns and peacemaking as an integral part of the Christian mission. Schreiter argues for adding reconciliation into Christian mission[32].

 

In the Willingen, it was stated that "The missionary movement of which we are part has its source in the triune God Himself. Out of the depths of His love for us, the Father has sent forth His beloved Son to reconcile all things to Himself, that we and all men might, through the Spirit, be made one in Him with the Father, in that perfect love which is the very nature of God". The Trinitarian aspect of God was emphasized in relation to mission. Interestingly the movement and mission are combined even in this Missio Deo paradigm. Interestingly there was a shift from the church-based mission approach to a God-based mission approach[33]. The concept of Missio Deo has radically challenged and changed many perceptions and perspectives on mission shifting the focus on activities and engagement of Trinitarian God in this world.

 

Some engaged critically arguing missio Dei is not going far enough to show solidarity with the people who are oppressed, marginalized and discriminated based on castes, colour, gender, and disability. This concept has not recognized the movement of people towards God which Thomas Thangaraj attributes as Missio Humanitas (Human Mission)[34] in which people show solidarity with the oppressed and engage in the liberation movement of God by showing solidarity with those who are oppressed. Here again, without seeing this as the participation of God’s ongoing salvific act, it becomes a mere mission of human being. We need to engage with God’s Mission while recognizing the human mission from different quarters towards God. Stephen Neil wrote, “if everything becomes mission nothing is mission”. Nevertheless, everything cannot become a Christian mission and so God’s Mission. To make a mission Christian, it needs to be recognized as “Missio En Deo (Mission in God)”. It is not merely a movement rather it leads to recognition of ‘God in us’ and ‘us in God’[35]. It is not mere self-realization rather it is a recognition that God is not only with us but also God is in us and we are in God.

 

Christian mission is not mere social activism. Christian mission is not mere fundamentalism trying to increase the number of Christians through proselytizing methods similar to Christendom missionary approaches. Christian mission includes witnessing (Martrya); evangelism (Evangelion); preaching (Kerygma); serving (Diakonia); emptying (Kenotic); uniting (Koinonia); listening (Pous); transforming (ktizo) and repenting (metanoia). In each context, this can vary.  The World Council of Churches tried to identify the word, ‘Mission’ as : Evangelion – to announce the good news (evangelism); Martyria  - to bear witness (IMC 1952);  Oikumene – to become one in/with Christ (ecumenism) – Koinonia (fellowship) (IMC 1947); Kerygma – to preach (IMC 1947); Didache – to teach (IMC 1947) and Diakonia – to serve (1967 Hoekendijk).[36]

In every context, the understanding, practice, and reflection of mission can vary and even stand in contradiction with what in other context is understood as the mission. We may have to remember what Bishop Neil wrote long back saying if everything is mission nothing is the mission[37]. Christian mission in some contexts has to emphasize the invitation of God to take part with him in his saving and preserving acts for this world while in other contexts restore broken human relationship and dignity which is often ignored or neglected. The question for us whether missio Dei and missio Humanitatis enable us to hold all these diverse characteristics of mission creatively and critically together. Also, human active involvement in mission along with and within God’s community and its interdependency, interconnectivity, inter-relationality, and interactivity with other beings within and outside God have not been recognized and emphasized much in missio Dei. In the following sections, we will discuss more in this area.

 

 

Missio En Deo

 

This concept of ‘Missio En Deo’ can also be recognized in the imageries of the Body of Christ where different parts of the body are held together. Paul develops these imageries in a number of instances particularly with a phrase ‘in Christ’ and also using the body of Christ language. In 1 Cor 12:27 Paul says, ‘Now you are the body of Christ, and members individually’, in verse18 he again tells us, ‘But now God has set the members, each one of them, in the body just as He please’ and again in Eph 5:30 ‘For we are members of His body, of His flesh and of His bones’. Paul goes on describing how each member or part operates within the body of Christ. This enables us to see the mission in God as mission within Trinity among themselves and expanded to human beings to play a role within this mission of God.  Recently people have brought the orthodox idea of ‘Theosis’ back into Christian mission. This has contributed a bit in shifting the idea of Missio Deo to Missio en Deo. This is developed by Paul S Fiddes (participating in God)[38] and Veli-Matte Karkkainen[39] (One with God) in their recent books. It is yet to be developed fully.

 

The idea of Trinity as a community which means that the idea of God as the other, Christ as within and the Holy Spirit as dwelling among us but incomprehensible mysteries and the “beyondness” of God is revealed and is concealed by the Holy Spirit. Nevertheless, the community is united but not in uniformity nor monolithic group, but keep the differences and so not the sameness. Therefore, unity in diversity and diversity in unity symbolically can describe the Trinity. Such a trinity is not a closed, fixed, or finished entity rather creatively growing and constructively open community into which everyone is invited to participate and join. The Eucharistic activities are ritual expression and invitation of people to participate in such unity while keeping and upholding the differences. While we keep this idea of Trinity as an open community and we as human beings are called not only to participate but also to become part of the mind and activities of God in this world. While keeping God as being with us means God is near us and working closely with us while allowing us closely work with God.

 

 

 

 

 

Missio Dei to Missio En Deo

 

Missio en Deo refers to mission within Godhood. First, the idea of reaching out to human beings or any other beings even the idea of creation arises from within the mind of God or from among the discussion or conversation or dialogue within the triune God or even wider community of God that might include angels and others in the spiritual realm who reside with God. When God created this world, human beings were created in the image of God and God created human beings to share and to participate in the purpose of recreating, up keeping and growing the created world along with him. God invited human beings to be part of his plans and actions for this earth. In this sense, God lets human being to be part of his mission to this world. In this, way while God being with him alongside, God is also within us an image of God and God as beyond who keeps watching over human beings with care and concern? Missio En Deo involves all these three aspects of engagement of God with human beings while it also lets human beings’ experience, knowledge, feelings and meanings to be brought into the core of Godhood and participate in the creative activities of God. At times this becomes human initiated in which God participates and at times it is God initiated in which human participates. In some places, it is both who are involved in initiating the mission as if both with the same mind and becoming one in enacting the vision and mission of God. Oneness is becoming one with God without becoming same as God (oneness does not mean sameness). The tension of being the other, being within, and being beyond are kept in a creative way, which is bonded together by the Holy Spirit within the human person.

 

Missio En Deo has implications that are different from missio Dei – a bit more or add to missio Dei. It is like becoming part of God’s plan and participate in the triune mind, heart, and soul of God. If human beings are the essential part of the triune God, then those who are involved with the mind of God would see their involvement with people with disabilities as a mandate and inevitable fulfillment of their own salvation not only in serving those but also being there for them. This highlights the interdependency of human beings among themselves in terms of their salvation, which means to be in perfect and imperfect relations with God. Perfect means restoration in fuller forms while imperfect means relating to God within the limited abilities of human beings as they are.

 

In simple words, if some are affected by HIV/AIDS such as children born for Christian families and are baptized in Christ, were like part of the body of Christ, which is the church. When we think of mission as missio En Deo, then our support, service, awareness, and help are not optional rather it is inevitable action of our faith, calling and salvation in Christ.  When a part of my body says hands are infected by germs, then the whole body cannot do charity to my hands rather responds as a body itself in order to get away with the germs and thus make sure that the hands are protected. In the same way when we are part of missio En Deo – mission within Godhood – then we see the other as part of ourselves within Godhood whom we serve sincerely and truly as if we are caring our own selves.

 

When we see others struggles as part of our own and showing solidarity with them means becoming Christ-like or participating along with God in the mission to grow within Godhood. At times we give importance to the parts of the body (to use Paul’s metaphor) because they are weak (not in terms of strength nor in terms of money) but in terms of power or in terms of being at margins. The weak body of God gets more attention in order to get it not only support and solidarity but also their dignity even in the case of them being at receiving end. 

 

Today, we need to look at missio en Deo as part of the churches mission because this would enable people with HIV/AIDS as part of our community in Christ. This view does not lead to condemnation nor to judgment rather towards healing and support. This can be seen as part of our calling and our relation with God in doing mission together with God and in discovering what we are along with God. This brings salvation as recognizing the purpose of our lives and living such purposes along with God having the mind of God involving in the acts of God and thereby participate in the triune God what is like looking and serving the world like God or Christ would do.

 

 

 

The relevance of Missio En Deo

In the context of individualism and self-centredness both through the modernity and postmodernity being promoted, the interdependency, interconnectedness, and inter-relationally of our essence of being with other beings are much emphasized in this concept of mission. Our salvation is not merely an individual achievement rather in relation to other beings and thus involve our participation in the essence of Triune God. Though much of the relational concept of Trinity is emphasized, there is also an emphasis in terms of substantial relations within Godhood and its openness to welcome human role for growth and dynamism.  Such a concept challenges both rational mind centered andro-centric approach (modernity) and self-centered worldview approach (post-modernity), rather takes us to a reality of humanity and other beings inter-relationally and interdependency in discovering purpose and meanings of life, truth and God together and thus face the change and growth together as part of dynamic reality of the Triune God. This helps us to be continually reflexive not only self but also communal and ecological and enable us to see God’s transcendental, immanence, Omnipresence in a creative way while our own participation and role within the Triune community and essence of God. This does not make us God because once we feel God we fall out of this community as pride takes over. This participation is also due to the generosity and hospitality of God that allows us to be in communion within Godhood and so it is a privilege for the realized and since disciple of Christ.

 

Recently I came across the questions of caring to differently able individuals by the family members and others. Recently the Church of England has raised her voice against abortions of the supposed to be an autistic fetus, which scientific, secular and rational thinking people have suggested to go for[40]. Caring such children have been seen as a Christian way of life and as part of Christian Calling. Sadly, when Christian (religious) values and so faith has become irrelevant in many contexts, people began to question a full time caring as something optional. In a sense, some began to argue that why we should have autistic children in the first place be born. In the sense that why should we allow them to be born and allow them to suffer their lives even though they are cared well by people in their families or by others. Even those who care to find themselves that they did not live their own lives and thus by caring for their lives too are not fully lived. So if an autistic child is killed at the early stages of the fetus then both the autistic child (who has to go through bullying, extra spending, supporting and caring) and their carers can be spared of their lives. I feel the theology of God being “the other” only has a problem in not supporting this view but challenging this view nevertheless it does not challenge the problem and does not make caring as part of one’s own salvation and part of one’s own self in Godhood. This is why I try to write this article of reconstructing because God as other has to be seen as God in us and God beyond us. But the idea that God beyond us has been well explained as unknown and known aspects or characteristics of God and God’s involvement in this world. Nevertheless the idea that God in us can be challenging for us in terms of making such caring as an inevitable part of our discipleship and in discovering our relations in Godhood.

 

 



[1] Michael Parsons. “In Christ” in Paul Vox Evangelica 18, 1988, pp. 25-44. https://biblicalstudies.org.uk/pdf/vox/vol18/in-christ_parsons.pdf

[2] A Schweitzer, The Mysticism of the Apostle Paul. ET London, 1953, p.16.

[3] H Ridderbos, Paul: An Outline of his Theology. ET London, 1977, p.59.

[4] J D G Dunn, Jesus and the Spirit. London. 1975, p.324.

[7] Charles L. Hunt, The Body of Christ: Separating Myth from Metaphor.  2006, http://pleasantviewbc.com/files/The_Body_of_Christ-entire_book.pdf

[8] Jorgan Moltman, History and Triune God. Contribution to Trinitarian Theology. Trans. John Bowden, New York: Crossroad, 1992, p.167.

[9] John O’Donnell, The Trinity as Divine Community: A Critical Reflection Upon Recent Theological Developments. Gregorianum Vol 69, 1, 1988 pp 5-34.

[10] Augustine De Trinitate VII: 8,12.

[11] Jeff Haines, Trinity as community 2006, https://www.academia.edu/3353418/The_Trinity_as_Community

[12] John Tucker Habets, Theosis in the Theology of Thomas Torrance Surrey, England. Ashgate 20019, 96

[13] Dick O. Eugenio, Communion with God: The Trinitarian Sociology of Thomas F Torrance. A PhD Thesis. Manchester: MU, 2011  https://www.escholar.manchester.ac.uk/api/datastream?publicationPid=uk-ac-man-scw:137109&datastreamId=FULL-TEXT.PDF and also J B Torrance, Worship, Community and the Triune God of Grace. D Grove: IVP. 1996.

[14] Tom F Torrance, The Trinitarian Faith: The Evangelical Theology of the Ancient Catholic Church. T & T Clark 1995.

[15] Tom F Torrance, The Trinitarian Faith: The Evangelical Theology of the Ancient Catholic Church. T & T Clark 1995.

[17] Veli-Matti Karkkainen, The Trinity: Global Perspectives. Louisville, KY: Wesminister, John Knox, 2007.

[19] M. Elsbernd & R. Bieringer, When love is not enough: A theo-ethic of justice. Liturgical Press, Collegeville 2002

[20] Pieter G.R. de Villiers, Union with the transcendent God in Philo and John’s Gospel. South Africa. http://www.scielo.org.za/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0259-94222014000100090

[21] James McPolin, Johannine Mysticism. https://www.theway.org.uk/back/18McPolin.pdf

[22]James McPolin, Johannine Mysticism  https://www.theway.org.uk/back/18McPolin.pdf p.27

[23] M. L. Appold, The Oneness Motif in the Fourth Gospel. Tubingen, 1976, pp 283-86.

[24] R. Brown, The Gospel according to John. Vol I, New York, I966, pp 51 I-i2

[25] Jn 6, 56; Io, 38; 14, Io-II. 17 . 20; I5, 4-7; I7, 21-26; I Jn 2, 6. o4-28; 3, 6. 24;

[26] Andrew F. Walls, The Cross-Cultural Process in Christian History: Studies in the Transmission and Appropriation of Faith. Maryknoll, N.Y: Orbis Books, 2002,

[27] N.E. Thomas, Classic Texts in Mission and World Christianity. Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books, 1995.

[28] N, E Thomas, Classic Texts, 1995

[29] Karl Hartenstein,   "Wozu nötigt die Finanzlage der Mission". Evangelisches Missions-Magazin. 1934, 79: 217–229

[30] Steven Bevans, God Inside Out; Notes Towards A Missionary Theology of the Holy Spirit. https://sedosmission.org/old/eng/Bevans.html

[31] Secretariat for Non‐Christians, “The Attitude of the Church toward the Followers of Other Religions, Reflections and Orientations on Dialogue and Mission,” Bulletin Secretariatus pro non Christianis, 56, 2. 

[32] J. Andrew Kirk, What Is Mission? Theological Explorations. London: Darton, Longman and Todd, 1999; Robert J. Schreiter, The Ministry of Reconciliation: Spirituality and Strategies. Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books, 1997. 

[33] Critically Analyse the Concept of Missio Dei and its Significance for Contemporary Mission. MA dissertation without name, https://www.academia.edu/14852823/Critically_Analyse_the_Concept_of_Missio_Dei_and_its_Significance_for_Contemporary_Mission_MAE3245

[34] Thomas Thangaraj, The Common Task: A Theology of Christian Mission, Abington Press, ABNDP, 1999.

[35] Stephen Neill, Creative Tension: The Duff Lectures, 1958. London: Edinburgh House Press, 1959, 81.

[36] Joshva Raja, Mission in Theological Education, a Review, https://rethinkingmission.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/joshva_mar_2011.pdf

[37] Stephen Neill, Creative Tension: The Duff Lectures, 1958. London: Edinburgh House Press, 1959, 81.

[38] Paul S Fiddes, Participating in God, A Pastoral Doctrine of Trinity. John Knox Press, Westminster, 2000.

[39] Veli-Matti Karkainnen, One with God, Salvation as Deification and Justification. The Liturgical Press, Collegeville, 2004.

[40] Olivia Rudgard, “Church of England set to lobby Government over rising Down's Syndrome abortions“ Telegraph News. 2018, https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/01/19/church-england-set-lobby-government-rising-downs-syndrome-abortions/

No comments: